The Proeger Family · Generation 7 — Kristin's 4th-great-grandparents
Solomon Cleveland
Probable father of Charles Edgar Cleveland · died 1845
On this page
On this page
Whose family are you here for?
Showing both families — every line on the page. Pick a side to hide the other family's ancestors; Earl, Kristin and their three children stay on either way.
Person · Solomon Cleveland
The record
- HHomethe fan · what changed · open questions
- MMigrationbirths and deaths on a map, by decade
- TTimeline1539 entries · 5 eras
- PPeople571 people, by generationSolomon Cleveland
- LLines13 surname pages
The evidence
The findings
How to read this record
Every claim is tagged
Most family trees flatten everything into the same confident typeface. This one does not. The three research tags below are the whole point of the exercise: they say what a document proves, what the weight of evidence suggests, and what nobody has found yet. A fourth marks what the family stated directly, where no document has been retrieved at all — it is kept separate on purpose and is never quietly promoted to confirmed. A fifth marks biological evidence: a DNA result is not a document, and it is not testimony either. Two further labels mark where this page withholds information rather than lacking it.
Attested by a document that was actually retrieved and read — a census sheet, a government index, a grave marker, a family-written obituary.
Strongly supported but not nailed down: a user-contributed tree, a masked index field, or a chain of consistent circumstances. Believable, not proven.
Searched for and not located. This is a statement about the search, not about the person — the record may well exist somewhere unsearched.
Supplied by the family and recorded on their word — no document has been retrieved for it. Note the diamond rather than the dot: this is provenance, not proof, and it stands apart from the three record tags above S24.
Biological evidence consistent with a claim. It corroborates origins; it does not by itself establish a person or a link. Note the bar rather than a dot or a diamond: no DNA result on this page is ever counted as confirmed, because no document was read for it S46.
The person is living. On the charts and in the chains of names a living person appears by name and relationship. A living adult’s full record is on their own card, published with the family’s consent and kept out of search engines. A minor appears by name only. The privacy note at the head of the page gives the rule in full.
A branch that is actively being worked on. The node exists in the structure so the shape of the family is honest; the detail is simply not in yet.
Solomon Cleveland
VermontProbableProbable father of Charles Edgar Cleveland · died 1845
- Born
- in St. Lawrence County, New York
- Died
- 22 October 1845
- Married
- Mrs. Mary Malinda (Thompson) Elliott (1834)
- Children
- Charles Edgar Cleveland
- Sources
- 25
- Images
- 1
Research status
Evidence: The printed Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (1899) enters him as Solomon Cleveland, died 22 October 1845 in Branch County, Michigan, husband of Mrs. Mary Malinda (Thompson) Elliott, and numbers Charles Edgar as his son; a FamilySearch index of Charles E. Cleveland's Nebraska marriage names his parents Solomen Cleveland and Mary Thompson. Weak or missing: The book is compiled and derivative and the Nebraska entry is an index with no image; no original record naming him has been found: the Branch County, Michigan probate index and the St. Lawrence County, New York surrogate indexes, read from the images, have no Cleveland entry for him or his children, and in the 1850 census index for Branch County the only Cleveland household is Benjamin, 28, of Butler Township, not his family; Charles's 1919 death certificate (S3094) gives his birth as 16 September 1845, five weeks before Solomon died, but his father only as Cleveland. Not yet confirmed. Know more? Confirm or correct this →
Life in the order the records give it
Solomon Cleveland is the probable father of Charles Edgar Cleveland. The printed Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (1899) gives his birth on 1 September 1806 at Poultney, Vermont, the eldest child of Enoch Cleveland and Parmelia Jenney; that is graded Probable S1316. The same book says he married the widow Mary Malinda (Thompson) Elliott at Lowville, New York, on 11 February 1834, or at Fowler, New York, on 14 April 1834; it gives both S822. In 1840 he was probably the Solomon Cleveland, 30 to 39, heading a household of six at Diana, Lewis County, New York, with an Enoch Cleveland on the line above S1003. He died on 22 October 1845 in California township, Branch County, Michigan, aged 39, by the book S822. The book numbers Charles Edgar as his son S467, and a marriage index names Charles’s parents as Solomen Cleveland and Mary Thompson S823. Charles’s 1919 death certificate gives his birth as 16 September 1845, five weeks before Solomon died, and his father only as Cleveland S3094; no original record names Solomon as his father. Another son, Albert E. Cleveland, born in St. Lawrence County, New York, named his parents as Solomon Cleveland and Mary Thompson when he married in Nebraska in 1895 S1139.
Family parents, marriages, children, siblings
5 Nov 2026 — Harriet Cleveland’s probable 1885 Greeley County household (S3433): her parents born in Rhode Island; children Wm S., Harmon and Lotta. SWEEP-1105K.
4 Nov 2026 — the searches for an original record are now stated: no Cleveland entry in the Branch County probate index or the St. Lawrence County surrogate indexes, and no Cleveland household of his in the 1850 Branch County census index; no grade changed. SWEEP-1104H (NP4-1104E/F).
4 Nov 2026 — the elder Enoch’s 1855 household with no wife (S3072) added to the 1841 mortgage item; no grade changed. SWEEP-1104G (NP4-1104C).
4 Nov 2026 — the 1841 Diana mortgage of Enoch and Loudisa Cleveland (S3323) and the two Enochs of the 1850 Diana census added as context; no grade changed. SWEEP-1104F (NP4-1104A/B).
1 Nov 2026 — Martha Rathbone in the 1850 Diana census (S3169). Still Probable. SWEEP-1101E.
1 Nov 2026 — Solomon’s birth, the 1788 deed, service and burial (S3143–S3146); Martha Rathbone’s birth at Canaan and her parents (S3147), replacing the book’s guess. Still Probable. SWEEP-1101C.
31 Oct 2026 — Charles’s 1919 death certificate (S3094) removes the conflict between his “about 1846” birth and Solomon’s 1845 death; Solomon stays Probable, strong. SWEEP-1031J.
31 Oct 2026 — Enoch’s parents Solomon Cleveland and Martha Rathbone (S3070, S3071, Probable); Parmelia’s birthplace; Enoch at Diana in 1855 (S3072), read from the image. PA-1031K. Enoch Cleveland at Diana in 1865 (S3069) and Josiah Cleveland’s 1871 Michigan death return (S3068), both read from the images. PA-1031J.
28 Oct 2026 — Albert E. (Emory) Cleveland’s son Willie S.(?), born at Newberg on 1 December 1868, added from the Cass County, Michigan birth return, read from the image (S2649). SWEEP-1028G.
26 Oct 2026 — his parents, Enoch Cleveland and Parmelia Jenney, named from the Cleveland genealogy (S1316, Probable) and added to the Ancestry tree; no grade changed (PA-1026Q).
The notes on this card that carried a “new” mark were added on these days: 29 Sep 2026 (1 note), 1 Oct 2026 (1 note). The marks and their dates were taken off on 12 Oct 2026, and nothing in the notes was changed.
Open questions what is probable, weak or missing — confirm or correct it
Photos & documents 0 portraits · 0 photos · 1 document
Documents (1)
Documents · 1 page image all documents
This image names its source in its own entry. The thumbnail opens the full image, which can also be downloaded.
Solomon Cleveland · Sources
Citations
Sources cited on this card
25 of the record's sources are cited here. The numbering is the record's own; the full list, with where else each is cited, is at Sources.
- S467Descendants of Moses Cleveland (printed genealogy), p. 1939, no. 11632: Charles Edgar Cleveland. Ancestry record 3845121. Image examined, read 25 September 2026. Probable Charles Edgar Cleveland, son of Solomon, married 11 April 1866 at Rives, Michigan, Victoria Janette Smith, born 19 March 1844 in Ohio, daughter of Jeremiah Smith and Patience Kittle. In Placer County, California, 1883. Children Anna Jane (1869), Milton (15 July 1873) and Ella. A derivative book. The parents' names agree with the marriage register (S463) and the 1880 census (S465); the ancestry back of Charles Edgar rests on the book alone.
- S822Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (1899), p. 1438, no. 5238: Solomon Cleveland. Ancestry collection 61157, record 3831102 (image 46155_b290469-01473). Image examined, read 28 September 2026. Probable “SOLOMON7 CLEVELAND (Enoch, Solomon, Enoch, Deliverance, Edward, Moses), d. California tp., Branch co., Mich., Oct. 22, 1845, a. 39, m. Lowville, N.Y., Feb. 11, 1834, or in Fowler, N.Y., Apr. 14, 1834, Mrs. Mary Malinda (Thompson) Elliott, b. Wightford, …” A compiled, derivative book; the same work as S467. The entry, with her birth and the list of children, runs onto the next page, which has not been read. Collection: North America, Family Histories.
- S823FamilySearch, Nebraska Marriages 1855–1995 — Charles E. Cleveland and Rachel Gibson, South Branch Township, Nance County, Nebraska. FamilySearch ark:/61903/1:1:QPQJ-17HD, checked 28 September 2026. Probable Charles E. Cleveland, born 1846; parents Solomen Cleveland and Mary Thompson; bride Rachel Gibson, 36, father W. Gibson; groom 39; married 7 September 1885 at South Branch, Nance County. Index only; FamilySearch shows no image. Evidently a later marriage of Charles Edgar, whose son Milton married in Nance County in 1896 (S463); his 1919 death certificate (S3094) has a wife Rachel as informant and his mother as Mary Thompson. Index only: reading the Nance County register would give Solomon from an image.
- S10031840 United States Federal Census — Diana, Lewis County, New York, page 19. Ancestry record 2399501. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Probable Solomon Cleveland, a man of 30–39, with a woman of 30–39, a boy under 5, a boy 10–14 and two girls 5–9. Enoch Cleveland, 50–59, heads the household on the line above, and Josiah Cleveland, 20–29, the one below. 1840 names only the heads. The 1810 and 1820 Poultney, Vt., hints for a Solomon Cleveland were a different, older man and are not used.
- S1139Hamilton County, Nebraska, Marriage Record D, p. 89 — Albert E. Cleveland and Anna C. Shaffer (13 November 1895). Ancestry record 1050231574. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Confirmed Licence of 13 November 1895: Albert E. Cleveland, 58, white, born St. Lawrence County, New York, of Greeley County, Nebraska, father Solomon Cleveland, mother’s maiden name Mary Thompson; Mrs. Anna C. Shaffer, 58, born Pennsylvania, of Hamilton County, father Henry Potter. Married the same day in Hamilton County by William R. Todd, preacher of the gospel. The bride’s mother’s surname (possibly Weaver) is hard to read.
- S1316The Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (E. J. and H. G. Cleveland, 1899), p. 728 — family 1694, Enoch Cleveland. Ancestry, “North America, Family Histories, 1500–2000”, record 3809407. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 28 September 2026. Probable Family 1694: Enoch Cleveland (Solomon, Enoch, Deliverance, Edward), died Carlton, Kewaunee County, Wisconsin, 13 March 1874, aged 88; married first, 1804, Parmelia Jenney of Vermont, born 1 January 1787, died Wilna, New York, 29 July 1832, daughter of Prince and Olive (Lincoln) Jenney; married second, about 1835, Boadicea McDonnell. Children by the first marriage begin +5238 Solomon Cleveland, born 1 September 1806, Poultney, Vermont; Charlotte Ann, born 1808, married Gideon Draper at Fowler, St. Lawrence County, New York, in 1833; Russell Wolcott, born 1810; Josiah, born 1812; Samuel, born and died 1814–15. A compiled genealogy printed in 1899, not an original record. Number 5238 ties this entry to the p. 1438 entry already cited (S822), whose “aged 39” in October 1845 agrees with September 1806. The book’s parents for Solomon have not yet been adopted on his card. PROBABLE.
- S26081900 U.S. Federal Census — Albert E. Cleavland household, Aurora 3rd Ward, Hamilton County, Nebraska (ED 80, sh. 16B). Ancestry record 32745534. Image examined, read 28 October 2026. Born May 1838 in New York, father born Vermont, mother born New York; retired wagon maker, owns; wife Anna C., married 5 years.
- S26091870 U.S. Federal Census — Emory Cleveland household, Newberg Township, Cass County, Michigan (p. 24). Ancestry record 41390888. Image examined, read 28 October 2026. Emory Cleveland, 32, born New York, farm labourer; Harriet, 32, born Ohio; five children.
- S26101860 U.S. Federal Census — Emery Cleveland, La Grange Township, Cass County, Michigan (p. 3). Ancestry record 44415046. Image examined, read 28 October 2026. Emery, 22, wagon maker, born New York, married within the year to Harriet, 21, born Ohio.
- S2649Michigan birth return — Willie S.(?) Cleveland, Newberg, Cass County (born 1868), p. 225, no. 231. Ancestry record 106991602. Image examined, read 28 October 2026. Born 1 December 1868 at Newberg; father Emory Cleveland, farmer, born New York; mother Harriet, born Ohio. The middle initial is unclear. The parents are the Emery/Emory and Harriet of the 1860 and 1870 censuses (S2610, S2609).
- S3068Sanilac County, Michigan, return of deaths for 1871, p. 191, no. 52 — Josiah Cleveland. Ancestry record 751403761. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading. Probable Died 18 April 1871 at Speaker, aged 58 years 6 months, married, a farmer, born Vermont; parents Enoch Cleveland and Amelia Cleveland, of Vermont. “Amelia” is read as a clerk’s Parmelia, written forty years after her death; the age fits the Cleveland genealogy’s Josiah, born 22 October 1812. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3069New York state census 1865 — Town of Diana, Lewis County, p. 45, lines 17–24, 29 June 1865. Ancestry record 991894. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading. Confirmed Enoch Cleveland, 79, born “Washington”, married twice, a farmer and landowner; children Lydia, 38, Alford, 36, married, a farmer, and William, 27; Alvira R., 31, son’s wife, mother of 3; grandchildren James, 12, Daniel, 10, and Adaline, 5. “Washington” may mean Washington County, New York, and does not overturn Fair Haven, Vermont. Daniel’s age is written over another figure. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3070The Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (1899), p. 298, no. 535 — Solomon Cleveland. Ancestry record 3798850. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading. Probable Solomon Cleveland, a Revolutionary soldier, died at Wilna, New York, on 16 June 1844, aged 90. He married at Canaan, Connecticut, Martha Rathbone or Rathbun of Stonington (1760–1850), daughter of Job and Abigail (Russel). Their child no. 1694 is Enoch, born 8 September 1786 at Fair Haven; also Almeda, Solomon, Patty or Martha, Abigail, who married Lorenzo Ward, Samuel (1793), Lydia and Fassett (1799). A compiled book, read from the page. Enoch’s death in 1874 is not on this page; it is on p. 728 (S1316). Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3071The Jenney Genealogy (typescript), p. 385, no. 286 — Pamelia Jenney. Ancestry record 4348011503. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading. Probable Pamelia Jenney, born at Dartmouth, Massachusetts, on 1 January 1787, died at Wilna on 29 July 1832; married about 1804 Enoch Cleveland (born Fair Haven 8 September 1786, died Carlton, Wisconsin, 13 March 1874, son of Solomon and Martha (Rathbone)). Enoch married second, about 1835, Boadicea McDonnell. Twelve children: Solomon (1 September 1806, Poultney), Charlotte Ann (1808), Russell Walcott (1810), Josiah (22 October 1812), a Samuel who died young (1814), Samuel (1817, Milan, Pennsylvania), Enoch (24 February 1819, Hadley, New York), Daniel (6 February 1820), Sophronia Almeda (21 May 1823), Lydia Pamelia (14 January 1827), Alfred (25 May 1829, Diana) and a son born and dead on 29 July 1832. A compiled typescript. The index joins the two wives and reads Josian where the page has Josiah. “Of Vermont” in the Cleveland genealogy is read as her home at marriage, and does not conflict with Dartmouth. It carries her line through a Prince, son of Seth, not tested here. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3072New York state census 1855 — Town of Diana, Lewis County, lines 32–39. Ancestry record 1655069784. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading. Confirmed Enoch Cleveland, 69, born Vermont, 26 years in the town, a farmer and landowner; children Lydia, 28, born St. Lawrence County, and William, 17, born Lewis County. Next door, dwelling 171: Enoch Cleveland, 36, born Saratoga County, a farmer, with his wife Lafrona(?), 30, and Laura F., 8, born Wisconsin, Philetus L., 5, and Myron W., 3. The index lists only three people; the son’s household next door is on the image. Twenty-six years in the town puts Enoch at Diana from about 1829. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3094Arkansas death certificate no. 426 — Charles E. Cleveland, Ouachita County, 11 June 1919. Ancestry collection 61777, record 79081, image 61777_01_00030-01973. Read from the image, 31 October 2026. Confirmed Born September 16, 1845, Michigan; married; farmer; father’s name given only as Cleveland; mother’s maiden name Mary Thompson. Informant Rachel Cleveland, Stephens, Ark.; the place is doubtful.
- S3143Barbour Collection, Canterbury, Connecticut, p. 168 — Solomon Cleveland. Ancestry record 58174. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Probable Solomon, son of Enoch and Deborah, born 27 February 1754 (vol. 1, p. 106). The next line is another Solomon, son of Silas and Elizabeth, born 21 April 1754, who is not him. An abstract; the town book was not seen. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3144The Genealogy of the Cleveland and Cleaveland Families (1899), p. 148, family 189 — Enoch Cleveland. Ancestry record 3796034. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Probable No. 535, Solomon, born 27 February 1754, recorded at Canterbury; quotes the deed of 1 September 1788 from Enoch to “my beloved son Solomon”. Compiled; the deed itself was not seen. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3145DAR Revolutionary War burial card — Solomon Cleveland. Ancestry record 4560. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Probable Born 27 February 1754, died 16 June 1844; Sand Hill Cemetery, Wilna, Jefferson County, New York; Private in the continental line. It may rest on the 1899 book. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3146DAR Patriot Index, p. 138 — Solomon Cleveland. Ancestry record 90015329. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Probable Born 26 February 1754, died 16 June 1844, married Martha Rathbone; Pvt Matr, Connecticut. One day off the town abstract, which is preferred. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3147Barbour Collection, Canaan, Connecticut, p. 74 — Martha Rathbun. Ancestry record 53862. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Probable Martha, daughter of Job and Abigail, born 4 March 1760; Job married Abigail Russell on 7 December 1758. An abstract; the register (LR2 227) was not seen, and the town comes from the index and the entries on the page. Replaces the 1899 book’s stated guess at her birthplace. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3158Pension Roll of 1835, Jefferson County, New York, p. 418 — Solomon Cleaveland. Ancestry record 38257. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Confirmed Private, $40 a year, Connecticut continental line, placed 3 January 1833, aged 78. The age fits 27 February 1754 at placement. The index’s “abt 1753” and enrolment of 4 March 1831 are wrong: that is the commencement date. This is the Revolutionary grandfather, not the Solomon of the card, who died in 1845. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S31691850 census, Diana, Lewis County, New York, dwelling 2331 — Fassett Cleaveland. Ancestry record 12342036. Read from the image (Stage 2 reading, 1 November 2026). Confirmed Martha, 90, born Massachusetts, in the household of Farsett Cleaveland, 50, and family. No relation stated; taken as Martha Rathbone by name, age and the book’s son Fassett. Canaan stands as her birthplace beside it. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3323Lewis County, New York, Mortgages 1836–1842: Enoch Cleveland and Loudisa Cleveland his wife, of Diana, to John Dempster, 1 October 1841, $465. FamilySearch Full-Text, image 3:1:3QS7-99W5-R9ZH. Read from the image, November 2026; the wife’s name reads Loudisa or Laodicea (uncertain), not Louisa as the transcript has it. Which Enoch made it is not settled: the book’s Enoch married Parmelia Jenney, and the younger Enoch of Diana had a wife Sophronia in 1850. Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
- S3433Nebraska state census, 1885, Spring Creek Precinct, Greeley County (ED 350, p. 43) — Harriet Cleveland. Ancestry record 1090727. Read 5 November 2026 (tree PA-1105J; site SWEEP-1105K). Harriet Cleveland, 47, wife, born Ohio, both parents born Rhode Island; Wm S., 16, Harmon, 11, and Lotta, 8, all born Michigan, father born New York. Matched on her name, age and birthplace and on Wm S. (Probable). Serves the card of Solomon Cleveland.
Know something this page doesn't? Send it to Earl — corrections, names, dates, documents. Nothing appears here until he has reviewed it.
