
The Proeger Family · Generation 5 — Earl's great-great-grandparents and their siblings
Lucinda Bowles Carpenter
Daughter of James Daniel Bowles · born 1870
On this page
On this page
Whose family are you here for?
Showing both families — every line on the page. Pick a side to hide the other family's ancestors; Earl, Kristin and their three children stay on either way.
Person · Lucinda Bowles Carpenter
The record
- HHomethe fan · what changed · open questions
- MMigrationbirths and deaths on a map, by decade
- TTimeline1539 entries · 5 eras
- PPeople571 people, by generationLucinda Bowles Carpenter
- LLines13 surname pages
The evidence
The findings
How to read this record
Every claim is tagged
Most family trees flatten everything into the same confident typeface. This one does not. The three research tags below are the whole point of the exercise: they say what a document proves, what the weight of evidence suggests, and what nobody has found yet. A fourth marks what the family stated directly, where no document has been retrieved at all — it is kept separate on purpose and is never quietly promoted to confirmed. A fifth marks biological evidence: a DNA result is not a document, and it is not testimony either. Two further labels mark where this page withholds information rather than lacking it.
Attested by a document that was actually retrieved and read — a census sheet, a government index, a grave marker, a family-written obituary.
Strongly supported but not nailed down: a user-contributed tree, a masked index field, or a chain of consistent circumstances. Believable, not proven.
Searched for and not located. This is a statement about the search, not about the person — the record may well exist somewhere unsearched.
Supplied by the family and recorded on their word — no document has been retrieved for it. Note the diamond rather than the dot: this is provenance, not proof, and it stands apart from the three record tags above S24.
Biological evidence consistent with a claim. It corroborates origins; it does not by itself establish a person or a link. Note the bar rather than a dot or a diamond: no DNA result on this page is ever counted as confirmed, because no document was read for it S46.
The person is living. On the charts and in the chains of names a living person appears by name and relationship. A living adult’s full record is on their own card, published with the family’s consent and kept out of search engines. A minor appears by name only. The privacy note at the head of the page gives the rule in full.
A branch that is actively being worked on. The node exists in the structure so the shape of the family is honest; the detail is simply not in yet.
Lucinda Bowles Carpenter
KentuckyConfirmedDaughter of James Daniel Bowles · born 1870
- Born
- 27 February 1870
- Died
- 28 September 1920
- Parents
- James Daniel Bowles & Lydia Williams
- Children
- Harry Charles Carpenter, Congress
- Sources
- 29
- Images
- 3
Research status
Life in the order the records give it
30 Oct 2026 — Emily Chilson’s 1940 census (S2834). PA-1030L.
28 Oct 2026 — Robert Marion Carpenter’s birth on 23 November 1866 and burial at Kingman (S2554) and the groom-side marriage index (S2555) added, Probable. SWEEP-1028A. 27 Oct 2026 — birth county Owsley (S2538) and residence at Cass in 1887 (S2539) added from indexes, Probable. SWEEP-1027N. 24 Oct 2026 — link to the new card(s) for the in-law parents added (SWEEP-1024A). 21 Oct 2026 — John C. Chilson’s probable parents from the 1880 Pinal County census (S2371). SWEEP-1021A.
The notes on this card that carried a “new” mark were added on these days: 29 Sep 2026 (4 notes), 1 Oct 2026 (1 note), 10 Oct 2026 (1 note), 11 Oct 2026 (1 note). The marks and their dates were taken off on 12 Oct 2026, and nothing in the notes was changed.
22 Sep 2026 — S158 was read again from the image at full resolution; what the re-read found is in the standing note of each source in the sources list, and the dated “supplement” label was taken off those notes on 12 Oct 2026. 13 Oct 2026 — the “Research status” line gave the day this card was added and entered in the family tree, 24 Sep 2026. The date was taken out of the sentence and stands here only; no fact or grade was changed. 13 Oct 2026 — the 1912 marriage read from the marriage book (S1684), William Lacy Carpenter’s 1953 death added (S1794), and Bessie’s parents rewritten from three images (S1795–S1797), replacing the 1900 census index. 14 Oct 2026 — William Lacy Carpenter Jr.’s corrected birth record (S1976) and Emily Jane Chilson in 1950 (S1963) added; no grade changed.
14 Oct 2026 — Emily Jane Chilson’s maiden name Gann, given as “probably”, is now stated from her 1891 marriage record (S1983), which agrees with her death certificate; the 1921 Phoenix directory (S1984) added. 14 Oct 2026 — the 1930 Winslow census (S2043, where he is recorded as Walter L.) and his 1942 draft card (S2044) added.
15 Oct 2026 — William Lacy Carpenter’s 1953 Arizona death certificate (S1794) added to the documents on this card, with the Social Security number blacked out; no wording or grade changed. 15 Oct 2026 — the 1917 Tempe directory entry for William Lacy and Bessie added, with Tempe for the index’s Phoenix (S2132).
Family parents, marriages, children, siblings
Open questions what is probable, weak or missing — confirm or correct it
Photos & documents 0 portraits · 0 photos · 3 documents
Documents (3)
Documents · 3 page images all documents
Each image names its source in its own entry. Each thumbnail opens the full image, which can also be downloaded.


Lucinda Bowles Carpenter — Ancestry coll. 8704 (Arizona, U.S., Death Records, 1887-1968), record 600216827, image 022_10222078-02047; Arizona State Board of Health, County Registered No. 9718, Local Registrar's No. 2439, filed 30 Sept 1920 · full resolution 2928 x 3984 px, 48/48 DeepZoom tiles — page certificate
William Lacy Carpenter (son of Lucinda Bowles Carpenter) — Arizona death certificate, Pima County 1953
Lucinda Bowles Carpenter · Sources
Citations
Sources cited on this card
29 of the record's sources are cited here. The numbering is the record's own; the full list, with where else each is cited, is at Sources.
- S158Arizona Certificate of Death, 1920 — LUCINDA CARPENTER, daughter of James Daniel Bowles, Phoenix, Maricopa County. Ancestry collection 60420, record 600216827. Arizona State Board of Health, Bureau of Vital Statistics, County Registered No. 9718, Local Registrar's No. 2439. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Lucinda Carpenter, F, White, married; date of birth Feb 27 1870, age 50, occupation Housewife, birthplace Kentucky; NAME OF FATHER: James Bowles; MAIDEN NAME OF MOTHER: Williams; informant R. N. Carpenter; died 28 September 1920, 3:30 p.m., of shock following operation at the Deaconess Hospital, attended from 12 August; buried Greenwood, 30 September 1920; usual residence California, about two years in Arizona. This is not James Daniel Bowles's death record, though Ancestry's index makes it look like one. The index surfaces the record under Name: James Bowles. On the image he appears in one box only — Name of Father. It is not cited as his death record; he died in 1889 in Texas. A second index error on the same card: "Spouse: Williams Bowles" is not a person. Williams is the maiden-name-of-mother box, a surname with no given name, read by the indexer as a man. What the certificate does settle is a daughter, fully. 27 February 1870, born Kentucky locks to the month against Lucinda, 4/12, born within the year — Feb on line 10 of the 1870 Owsley schedule S157. It also corroborates Lydia's maiden surname from another state entirely — Arizona, fifty years and two thousand miles from Owsley County, from a family informant. Williams rests on three independent documents: the 1856 marriage register S143, the 1858 birth register S160 and this. What is rejected here, and why. The certificate gives Virginia for both of her parents' birthplaces. Both are rejected. James was born in Estill County, Kentucky on his own marriage register S143 and Kentucky on three schedules; Lydia was born in Tennessee on two. The informant was a son-in-law reporting in 1920 on a father-in-law thirty years dead. The likely source of the slip is recoverable and is worth stating: James's own parents, Wm A. and Lucy Bowles, were born in Virginia S155 — the informant was one generation out, not simply wrong. A death certificate is primary for the death and hearsay for the parents. Both parents' Virginia birthplaces were checked against the other records. Lydia's is wrong too. Three contemporaneous records give her Tennessee — the 1850 Owsley schedule while she was living at home [S173], the 1856 bride's column [S143], and the 1860 Travellers Rest sheet [S171] — and her son's 1936 Texas certificate gives a third answer, Kentucky. Two informants, two different wrong answers, sixty and eighty years on. Tennessee stands; the pattern is the finding. The Virginia is weak sideways corroboration of the Virginia-born generation in [S155] and worthless for either James's or Lydia's own birthplace.
- S957Arkansas delayed certificate of birth no. 166 — William Lacy Carpenter, born near Little Rock, Pulaski County, 29 July 1888 (sworn 27 November 1942, filed 9 January 1943). Ancestry record 300663443. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 24 September 2026. Confirmed Child William Lacy Carpenter, male, born 29 July 1888 at 2 a.m., in the country near Little Rock, Pulaski County. Father Robert M. Carpenter, 24, farmer, born Kentucky; mother Lucinda Bowles, 22, housewife, born Kentucky; no earlier children. Affiant Nannie E. Evans, of Wallowa, Oregon, who gives her relationship as aunt, sworn before a notary at Emmett, Gem County, Idaho. The certificate was made 54 years after the birth, and the parents' ages are recollections. Lucinda's own death certificate and the 1870 census (S158) put her birth in February 1870, not about 1866, and the 1900 census gives Robert's as November 1866; the site keeps both. The index reads the middle name as "Lasy"; the image has Lacy. Lucinda's sister Nancy Ann Bowles married George R. Evans, so the affiant is probably she, but the certificate does not say so. Collection: Arkansas, U.S., Birth Certificates, 1914–1925.
- S9641880 United States Federal Census — Hilburn Township, Madison County, Arkansas, ED 104, page 32, dwelling 274 (22 June 1880). Ancestry record 39681260. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 24 September 2026. Confirmed William Carpenter, 41, head, farmer, born Kentucky, parents born Tennessee; Ala, 34, wife, born Kentucky; sons John 17, Robert 14 (farm laborer), Charles D. 12, and daughters Margarett 15, all born Kentucky; Amanda 10, Mary J. 8, Eliza B. 6, Sarah E. 4, Lyllian 2 and Josephine 1, all born Arkansas. The household is read in full. That this Robert is Robert Marion Carpenter, who married Lucinda Bowles in 1887, is Probable: Kentucky birth, age and Arkansas residence fit, and his daughter Ala E. was named for his mother, but no record yet names his parents. Collection: 1880 United States Federal Census.
- S9831880 U.S. census — Hilburn Township, Madison County, Arkansas, ED 104, page 25, 16 June 1880, lines 1–4. Ancestry record 6421264. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 28 September 2026. Confirmed A household continued from the previous page: Martha E., 12, and Lucinda, 10, born Kentucky, at school, then Sarah F., 7, and Lydia J., 5, both born Arkansas; all four with parents born Kentucky. The head of the household, James Boles, is on the previous page, which has not been read. Lucinda's age and Kentucky birth fit her birth on 27 February 1870 (S158). The younger girls' Arkansas births place the family's move from Kentucky about 1870–73.
- S984U.S. Army Transport Service passenger list — 242nd Military Police Company, port of embarkation Liverpool, England, sheet 2 (date blank, after the First World War), line 45. Ancestry record 129837644. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 28 September 2026. Probable Harry C. Carpenter, private first class, army no. 2311994; to be notified in emergency: Mrs Lucinda Carpenter, mother, Phoenix, Arizona. Phoenix is where Lucinda Bowles Carpenter died on 28 September 1920 (S158), so this is probably her son. The list gives no age or birthplace for him, and no other record read names him as her son.
- S1140City of Oswego, New York, Record of Marriages, p. 853, no. 856 — Harry Charles Carpenter and Florence Ethel Snyder (11 January 1921). Ancestry record 1050051680. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Confirmed Licence of 5 January 1921: Harry Charles Carpenter, white, 21, of R.F.D. 1, Phoenix, Arizona, soldier, first marriage, born Prescott, Arizona, father Robert M. Carpenter, mother Lucinda Bowles; Florence Ethel Snyder, 18, of Oswego, candymaker, born Oswego, father Albert Snyder, mother Frances Clark. Married 11 January 1921 at Oswego by Merritt J. Winchester, clergyman; future address Madison Barracks, New York.
- S1336Yavapai County, Arizona, register of electors, Prescott South precinct, p. 75, no. 213, 7 May 1914 — R. M. Carpenter. Ancestry, “Arizona, U.S., Voter Registrations, 1866–1955”, record 923126. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Confirmed Carpenter, R. M., laborer, 47, born Kentucky, living at South Prescott; signed “R M Carpenter”; 5 ft 10 in, 135 lb, white, dark hair, blue eyes. Initials only. The identification rests on his age (born about 1866–67), Kentucky and Prescott, where their son Harry was born.
- S1661“Return to Wickenburg” — Arizona Republican (Phoenix), 2 October 1920, p. 10. Tempe column. Newspapers.com, machine-read page text read on 2 October 2026; the page image was not re-checked. W. L. Carpenter, his wife and baby returned to Wickenburg after a week at the J. C. Chilson home; “Mrs. Carpenter was formerly Miss Bessie Chilson. Mr. Carpenter was called to Phoenix last Tuesday on account of his mother’s death.” The mother is not named. No obituary or death notice for Lucinda Carpenter was found in the eleven Phoenix pages read for 28 September to 8 October 1920.
- S1684Arizona marriage record and two indexes — William Lacy Carpenter and Bessie Chilson, Tempe, Maricopa County, 27 October 1912. Ancestry collection 60236, record 23786, and collection 60873, record 377313; the marriage book itself (Maricopa County, page 76; record 900377313) read from the image on 13 October 2026: licence of 25 October 1912 to William L. Carpenter, 24, of Yuma County and Bessie Chilson, 20, of Maricopa County; married 27 October 1912 at Tempe by E. P. Carr, Justice of the Peace; witnesses J. B. Armer and Wilmirth Chilson (so read); filed 30 October 1912. The index spells him “Carpinter”; the licence and his signature say Carpenter. Her birth, May 1892 in Arizona, is from the index of the 1900 census of Gila County (Ancestry collection 7602, record 14762394), also not read from the image. The Arizona Republican of 2 October 1920 calls her “formerly Miss Bessie Chilson, of Tempe” [S1661].
- S17861920 census — Congress, Yavapai County, Arizona, ED 112, sheet 2A, lines 6–8 — William L. Carpenter household. Ancestry, “1920 United States Federal Census”, records 71629415 and 71629416. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 13 October 2026. Confirmed William L. Carpenter, 30, born Arkansas, both parents born Kentucky, a mechanical engineer with a wrecking company; his wife Bessie, 27, born Arizona, her father born California and her mother Oregon; and a son William L., 6, born Arizona; 6 January 1920. ⚠ His age is a year under the 29 July 1888 of his delayed birth certificate, which stands.
- S1794Arizona death certificate of William Lacy Carpenter, Pima County, 1953. Arizona state file no. 1316; Ancestry record 161716. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 13 October 2026. Confirmed William Lacy Carpenter, machinist in aircraft work, born 29 July 1888 in Arkansas, died 4 February 1953 at 7272 Nogales Highway, outside Tucson, Pima County; 52 years in Arizona; father Robert M. Carpenter, mother Lucinda Bowles, born in Kentucky; informant his wife, Bessie I. Carpenter; the body removed to Phoenix on 6 February 1953. ⚠ No cemetery is named. The Social Security number is blacked out on the published copy.
- S1795Arizona death certificate of Emily Jane Chilson, Wickenburg, 1958. Arizona state file no. 6608; Ancestry record 173001. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 13 October 2026. Probable Emily Jane Chilson, widow, of 1303 East 8th Street, Tempe, born 20 January 1872 in Oregon, died 9 September 1958 at Wickenburg, buried 11 September 1958 at Greenwood, Phoenix; father A. J. Gann. ⚠ The informant was not a parent; the 1900 census index gives her birth as March 1874.
- S17961870 census, San Salvador Township, San Bernardino County, California, page 93 — the household of Emer Chilson. Ancestry record 826454. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 13 October 2026. Probable Emer Chilson, 28, farmer, born Illinois; Margaret, 19, born Texas; John C., 2, born Texas; and an infant daughter. ⚠ His 1924 death certificate gives California as his birthplace; both are shown.
- S1797Arizona death certificate of John C. Chilson, Phoenix, 1924. Arizona state index no. 134; Ancestry record 486121. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 13 October 2026. Confirmed John C. Chilson, stock man, of Tempe, husband of Emily Chilson, born in California, died at Phoenix on 4 January 1924, buried at Greenwood on 7 January 1924. ⚠ The form gives his birth as 7 November 1865 and his age as 56, which disagree; no birth year is taken from it.
- S19631950 census — Maricopa County, Arizona, ED 7-63, sheet 2, line 18 — Emily Jane Chilson. Ancestry, record 12334119. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Probable Chilson, Emily Jane, head, 78, widowed, born in Oregon, alone at 1303 East 8th Street; the same house in 1949. The page names no children; that she is the mother of Bessie Chilson Carpenter is Probable.
- S1976Arizona, affidavit correcting a birth record — William Lacy Carpenter Jr., Tempe, 30 July 1913 (sworn 1941). Ancestry, record 300009161. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Confirmed Born at Tempe, 30 July 1913, attended by Dr. B. B. Moeur; corrected entries: father 25, born at Fayetteville, Arkansas, machinist; mother 21, born at Payson, Arizona. Sworn by Bessie (Chilson) Carpenter of Atolia, California, and W. L. Carpenter Sr. of Redding, California.
- S1983Gila County, Arizona, marriage book, p. 19 — Chilson and Gann, 1891. Ancestry, record 318085. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Confirmed Licence 3 August 1891; John C. Chilson and Emily Gann married 6 August 1891 at the house of Jack Gann, by G. W. Jacobs, J.P. Ancestry’s index reads the bride’s surname “Garrer”; the image reads Gann.
- S1984Phoenix, Arizona, city directory, 1921 (year from the index), pp. 190–191 — Chilson. Ancestry, record 1017373740. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Confirmed “Chilson John C (Emily) (Chilson Bros) r Tempe”; Chilson Bros (N. W., J. B. and J. C.), distributors of Franklin motor cars, 232–34 W. Adams.
- S20431930 U.S. census, Winslow, Navajo County, Arizona, E.D. 9-10, sheet 7A, lines 41–43 — Carpenter. Ancestry, record 114938799. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Probable Walter L. Carpenter, 41, born in Arkansas, parents born in Kentucky, married at 24, garage manager, owns 504 Maple; Bessie I., 37, born in Arizona, married at 21, father born in California, mother born in Oregon; one son. The given name Walter is against William on every other record.
- S2044U.S. WWII draft registration card U-658 — William Lacy Carpenter, 1942. Ancestry, record 10355198. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Confirmed William Lacy Carpenter, 53, born 29 July 1888 at Little Rock, Arkansas; 2309 West Powell, Gresham, Multnomah County, Oregon; no employer; contact Otto Bruce, Gresham.
- S2132Tempe (1917) city directory, in the Phoenix directory volume, p. 415 — Carpenter, Wm L. (Bessie). Ancestry, “U.S., City Directories, 1822-1999”, record 843007948. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 15 October 2026. Confirmed Carpenter Wm L (Bessie), Tempe Garage Co., house 1131 Van Ness Avenue, under the page head Tempe (1917). ⚠ The index gives Phoenix because the section is bound in the Phoenix volume; the page says Tempe.
- S23711880 U.S. census, Miami, Pinal County, Arizona Territory, dwelling 1, household of E. L. Chilson. Ancestry record 15197489. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0740, 19 Oct 2026). Probable E. L. Chilson, 39, merchant, born Illinois; M. A., 29, born Texas; John, 12, son; Charles, Maggie, Napoleon, Guy. Gives John’s birthplace as Arizona, against Texas (1870) and California (1924).
- S2538Find a Grave Index — Lucinda Carpenter. Ancestry record 19905514. Index only, read 27 October 2026. Born in Owsley County, Kentucky.
- S2539Arkansas County Marriages index — Lucinda Boles. Ancestry record 2998710. Index only, read 27 October 2026. Married Robert Marion Carpenter, 2 October 1887; she of Cass, Franklin Co.
- S2554Find a Grave Index — Robert Marion Carpenter. Ancestry record 92305411. Index only, read 28 October 2026. Born 23 November 1866, Kentucky; buried at Kingman, Mohave Co., Arizona. The cemetery is not indexed.
- S2555Arkansas County Marriages index — Robert Marion Carpenter. Ancestry record 926258. Index only, read 28 October 2026. The groom’s entry for the 2 October 1887 marriage to Lucinda Boles (S2539).
- S28341940 census — Emily J. Chilson, Maricopa County, Arizona, ED 7-79, sheet 7A, line 24. Ancestry record 79019293. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 23 October 2026. Probable Emily J. Chilson, 68, a widow, born in Oregon, owner of her home; her son Bert, 36, a mechanic, and his wife Ora Lee, 33. The index’s Arizona birthplace is wrong; the image says Oregon. Grandchildren are not named. Serves the card of Lucinda Bowles Carpenter.
- S2845Great Register, Maricopa County, Arizona Territory, no. 6316 — Jno. C. Chilson. Ancestry record 531708. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 23 October 2026. Confirmed Jno. C. Chilson, 40, born in California, of Tempe, registered 29 August 1908. Serves the card of Lucinda Bowles Carpenter.
- S28541950 census — William L. Carpenter, Gila County, Arizona, ED 4-29, sheet 1, line 9. Ancestry record 12227370. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 23 October 2026. Confirmed William L. Carpenter, 61, born in Arkansas, a mine mechanic; Bessie T. or I., 57, born in Arizona; on the Payson-Globe Highway; neighbour Charles L. Chilson, 56, a cattle rancher. The neighbour’s relation is not stated. Serves the card of Lucinda Bowles Carpenter.
Know something this page doesn't? Send it to Earl — corrections, names, dates, documents. Nothing appears here until he has reviewed it.
