The Proeger Family · Generation 4 — Earl's great-grandparents and their siblings
Louise Bell Martin Harsh
Daughter of Joseph Daniel Martin · born 1866
On this page
On this page
Whose family are you here for?
Showing both families — every line on the page. Pick a side to hide the other family's ancestors; Earl, Kristin and their three children stay on either way.
Person · Louise Bell Martin Harsh
The record
- HHomethe fan · what changed · open questions
- MMigrationbirths and deaths on a map, by decade
- TTimeline1539 entries · 5 eras
- PPeople571 people, by generationLouise Bell Martin Harsh
- LLines13 surname pages
The evidence
The findings
How to read this record
Every claim is tagged
Most family trees flatten everything into the same confident typeface. This one does not. The three research tags below are the whole point of the exercise: they say what a document proves, what the weight of evidence suggests, and what nobody has found yet. A fourth marks what the family stated directly, where no document has been retrieved at all — it is kept separate on purpose and is never quietly promoted to confirmed. A fifth marks biological evidence: a DNA result is not a document, and it is not testimony either. Two further labels mark where this page withholds information rather than lacking it.
Attested by a document that was actually retrieved and read — a census sheet, a government index, a grave marker, a family-written obituary.
Strongly supported but not nailed down: a user-contributed tree, a masked index field, or a chain of consistent circumstances. Believable, not proven.
Searched for and not located. This is a statement about the search, not about the person — the record may well exist somewhere unsearched.
Supplied by the family and recorded on their word — no document has been retrieved for it. Note the diamond rather than the dot: this is provenance, not proof, and it stands apart from the three record tags above S24.
Biological evidence consistent with a claim. It corroborates origins; it does not by itself establish a person or a link. Note the bar rather than a dot or a diamond: no DNA result on this page is ever counted as confirmed, because no document was read for it S46.
The person is living. On the charts and in the chains of names a living person appears by name and relationship. A living adult’s full record is on their own card, published with the family’s consent and kept out of search engines. A minor appears by name only. The privacy note at the head of the page gives the rule in full.
A branch that is actively being worked on. The node exists in the structure so the shape of the family is honest; the detail is simply not in yet.
Louise Bell Martin Harsh
TennesseeConfirmedDaughter of Joseph Daniel Martin · born 1866
- Born
- 13 November 1866
- Died
- 13 February 1935
- Parents
- Joseph Daniel Martin & Nannie Chenault
- Married
- Nathan James Harsh (1860)
- Children
- Nannie Mai Harsh
- Sources
- 27
Research status
Life in the order the records give it
7 Nov 2026 — Dr Philip Harsh’s birthplace: Oppenheim (Find a Grave) and “Offenheim” (1880 census) are both shown, which is meant is open. NP11-1107B, SWEEP-1107G.
24 Oct 2026 — link to the new card(s) for the in-law parents added (SWEEP-1024A). 21 Oct 2026 — Nathan’s father George Harsh now has his own card (link Confirmed on S503); no grade on this card changed. SWEEP-1021D.
21 Oct 2026 — Thomas Walker Harsh’s 1946 Tennessee death certificate, read from the image (S2384), added: he is a half-brother of Nathan, son of George’s third wife Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds, the first record read that names her as George’s wife. No grade changed. SWEEP-1021B.
The notes on this card that carried a “new” mark were added on these days: 10 Oct 2026 (1 note). The marks and their dates were taken off on 12 Oct 2026, and nothing in the notes was changed. 13 Oct 2026 — 3 notes on this card ended with the words “added” and a date; they were added on: 24 Sep 2026 (1 note), 25 Sep 2026 (2 notes). The dated endings were taken off, and nothing else in the notes was changed. 13 Oct 2026 — the “Research status” line gave the day this card was added and entered in the family tree, 24 Sep 2026. The date was taken out of the sentence and stands here only; no fact or grade was changed.
14 Oct 2026 — “no marriage record has been found” rewritten for Nannie: the register index, newspaper notices and Long’s Rutherford family history (S1990) all name the marriage; no grade changed. 18 Oct 2026 — Nathan’s father George Harsh: dates, second wife Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds and parents Dr Philip Harsh and Magdalena Kehler added from Find a Grave 129937918 (S2272), Probable; the cousin link to Philip Harsh Rutherford noted. PA-1018K. 18 Oct 2026 — Nathan’s sister Elizabeth Caroline and her marriage to Colby Burris Chenault Jr. added (S2274), Probable. PA-1018L. 18 Oct 2026 — George Harsh’s wives corrected from two to three (Mary S. O. Guthrie 1851, Talitha Newby 1856, Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds probably 1878): Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds was his third wife, not his second, from the 1887 Goodspeed sketch (S2276); Callie named as Talitha’s daughter; no grade changed. SWEEP-1018P. 18 Oct 2026 — Elizabeth Caroline (Callie) Harsh entered in the family tree as a daughter of George Harsh (PA-1018O); nothing on this card changed. 19 Oct 2026 — Callie’s marriage now from the 1886 licence image (S2286), and the couple’s 1910, 1920 and 1940 census pages added (S2308–S2310); the line had said her marriage was on Find a Grave pages only. SWEEP-1019E. 19 Oct 2026 — George Harsh’s 1860 Goodlettsville household (S2353) added beside his second marriage. SWEEP-1019F.
Family parents, marriages, children, siblings
Open questions what is probable, weak or missing — confirm or correct it
Louise Bell Martin Harsh · Sources
Citations
Sources cited on this card
27 of the record's sources are cited here. The numbering is the record's own; the full list, with where else each is cited, is at Sources.
- S191Texas death certificate no. 10375 — Mrs. Bell Harsh, Abilene, Taylor County, 13 February 1935. Ancestry record 773424312. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Mrs. Bell Harsh, born 13 November 1866, Tennessee, of Gallatin, Tenn., died 13 February 1935 at 250 College Dr., Abilene; buried Gallatin; parents Joseph D. Martin and Nannie Chenault; informant Walter H. Adams. A daughter of Joseph D. Martin and Nannie Chenault — identified by the Rutherford family book as Louise Martin, wife of Nathan James Harsh [S204]. The given name before "Bell" is not legible on this certificate.
- S2021870 U.S. Federal Census — Joseph D. Martin household, District 12, Sumner County, Tennessee (P.O. Gallatin). Ancestry record 14376304. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Joseph D. Martin, 37, farmer; Nannie, 26; Louisa, 3; Mary, 1. Louisa is Louise Bell (Martin) Harsh [S191] [S204]; Mary, 1, is Mary Jane Martin, who has a card of her own. His age of 37 agrees with the 1832 on his headstone, the birth year his card gives.
- S204Gen. Griffith Rutherford and Allied Families (Harsh), page 175. Ancestry record 4440717068. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Nathan James Harsh (2 December 1860 – 10 October 1934) "married Miss Louise Martin … She died February 1935. Was dtr. of Joseph Martin and Nancy Chenault Martin." Mrs. Bell Harsh of the 1935 certificate [S191] is Louise (Louisa) Bell Martin, the Louisa of 1870 [S202]. The book is a derivative; its "originally of North Carolina" loses to the censuses, and page 176 has not been read.
- S2071880 U.S. Federal Census — Martin household, 10th Civil District, Sumner County, Tennessee. Ancestry record 16828687; ED 214, page 32. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Martin [given name left blank], 47, farming; Nannie, 36, parents both born Kentucky; children Luisa B. 13, Mary 11, Emma 10, Kate 7, Mattie 5, Joe 3 and Nannie 1. Two more children: Kate (c.1873) and a son Joe (c.1877), each with a card of their own, Kate Martin and Joseph Daniel Martin Jr. Mattie is Martha Martin McConnell [S203]; Nannie, 1, is Nancy Louise (Martin) Timberman.
- S401Sumner County, Tennessee, County Marriage Record, p. 134, entry 6 — N. J. Harsh and Louisa B. Martin, 17 October 1888. Ancestry record 5605204. Image examined, read 24 September 2026. Confirmed Licence issued at Gallatin, 17 October 1888, to N. J. Harsh to marry Louisa B. Martin (Harris Brown, clerk); return: married the same day by R. W. Harsh, M.G.
- S4021900 U.S. Federal Census — N. J. Harsh household, 1st Civil District, Sumner Co., Tennessee (ED 109, sheet 4B, lines 51–59). Ancestry record 61297028. Image examined, read 24 September 2026. Confirmed N. J. Harsh, 38, farmer owning his farm free, married 12 years; wife Louise, born May 1867, 33, mother of 4 children, 4 living; children Kenneth, Joe D., Nannie M. and Nathan; three servants; enumerated 7 June 1900. May 1867 differs from the 13 November 1866 of her death certificate (S191); both are second-hand, and neither is settled.
- S4031910 U.S. Federal Census — N. J. Harsh household, Civil District No. 1, Sumner Co., Tennessee (ED 131, sheet 3B, lines 67–73). Ancestry record 129782370. Image examined, read 24 September 2026. Confirmed N. J. Harsh, 49, farmer and employer, owning his farm free, married 21 years; wife Louise, 43, mother of 8 children, 5 living; children Kenneth, Joseph, Nannie M., Louise B. and Richard K.; enumerated 19 April 1910.
- S4041920 U.S. Federal Census — Nathan J. Harsh household, Harsh Road, First District, Sumner Co., Tennessee (ED 117, sheet 7A, lines 37–42). Ancestry record 36254186. Image examined, read 24 September 2026. Confirmed Nathan J. Harsh, 59, farmer, owning his farm free; wife Louise M., 53; sons Kenneth and Joe D., daughter Louise B. and son Richard; enumerated 16–17 January 1920.
- S4051930 U.S. Federal Census — Nathan J. Harsh household, Greenfield Road, 1st Civil District, Sumner Co., Tennessee (ED 83-1, sheet 7A, lines 19–25). Ancestry record 66186570. Image examined, read 24 September 2026. Confirmed Nathan J. Harsh, 69, farmer, owning his farm, with a radio; wife Louise, 63, first married at 22; their son Kenneth, 40, his wife Hattie and three grandchildren; enumerated April 1930.
- S503Tennessee, U.S., Death Records — certificate 21866: Nathan James Harsh, 1934. Ancestry record 200652. Image examined, read 25 September 2026. Confirmed Nathan James Harsh, husband of Louise, born 2 December 1860, died 10 September 1934 at Gaston Hospital, Lebanon; father George Harsh, mother Talitha Newby; informant J. D. Harsh, Gallatin; buried Gallatin. The certificate gives George's birthplace as Tennessee; the 1870 census (S504) says Pennsylvania, and is the better witness.
- S5041870 U.S. Federal Census — George Harsh household, Davidson County, Tennessee. Ancestry record 4468172. Image examined, read 25 September 2026. Confirmed George Harsh, 43, dry goods merchant, born Pennsylvania; Talitha, 36; Philip W.; Mary; Nathan, 10; Caroline; and a younger child whose name is hard to read.
- S5881880 U.S. census — 1st Civil District, Sumner County, Tennessee, ED 208, p. 25. Ancestry record 10076325. Image examined, read 25 September 2026. Confirmed George Harsh, 53, farmer, born in Pennsylvania, his father born at “Offenheim”, Germany; Elizabeth, 30, wife; Mary 20; Nathan, 19, son; Callie, Cheatman, George, Herbert, William and Walker; James Polk, 6, stepson. The Ancestry index gives Tennessee for George and both his parents; the page says Pennsylvania and Germany.
- S13111870 census — Phillip Harsh household, 18th Civil District, Davidson County, Tennessee, p. 18. Ancestry, “1870 United States Federal Census”, record 4476247. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 25 September 2026. Probable Dwelling 92, family 95: Phillip Harsh, 73, retired merchant, born Germany, real estate $16,000; Magdaline, 65, born Pennsylvania; William, 45; Lydia A. Rutherford, 35, born Pennsylvania, father foreign-born; Phillip H., 12, born Tennessee, at school; and James G., 11, born Tennessee. The 1870 census states no relationships. Phillip H. Rutherford is taken to be Mary Jane Martin’s husband by name and age (born c.1858), and Lydia as his mother; that she was a Harsh rests on her living in Phillip Harsh’s house and on her son’s middle name. PROBABLE.
- S1613Death and funeral notices of Mrs. Louise M. Harsh, Abilene, Texas, and Nashville, Tennessee, 1935. Abilene Daily Reporter, 13 February 1935, p. 5 (“Death Takes Mrs. Harsh”); Nashville Banner, 13 February 1935, p. 12, and 14 February, p. 18; The Tennessean, 14 February 1935, p. 14 (“Harsh Rites Friday”); Newspapers.com. Read from the page text (OCR), not from the page images. Confirmed Aged 68, of Gallatin; died Tuesday (12 February) at 2:15 p.m. at the home of a daughter, 250 College Drive, Abilene, where she was spending the winter; widow of Nathan J. Harsh; survived by two daughters, Mrs. Walter H. Adams of Abilene and Mrs. A. M. Timberman of Nashville; three sons, Kenneth of Watertown, Joe and Richard of Gallatin; two sisters, Mrs. Timberman and Mrs. Nancy Rutherford of Nashville; a brother, Joe Martin of Memphis; five granddaughters (not named here); funeral Friday 15 February; burial at Gallatin; Kiker-Knight Mortuary, Abilene. No parents are named. The papers disagree with each other and with the certificates on four points: the death day (Tuesday the 12th here, the 13th on her death certificate); whether Mrs. Nancy Timberman was her sister (Nashville) or her daughter (Abilene); her husband’s death, “last October 17” here against 10 September 1934 on his certificate; and the sister printed as Nancy Rutherford, where the Rutherford sister on this record is Mary Jane. The 13 February Banner prints the brother as John Martin.
- S1652Nannie Mai Harsh — Tennessee delayed birth record, Texas death certificate of Nancy Timberman (1982), and the 1920 census, Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. Ancestry collection 2282, record 311280; collection 2272, record 1356396; collection 6061, records 67359799 and 67359798 (image 4384794_00345). The birth record and death certificate are read from the indexes; the 1920 census page was read from the image on 13 October 2026. Birth record: Nannie Mai Harsh, born 7 January 1894 at Castalian Springs, Sumner County; father Nathan J. Harsh, mother Louise B. Martin. Death certificate: Nancy Timberman, also indexed Nancy Harsh, born 7 January 1894 in Tennessee; died 1 January 1982 at Abilene, Taylor County, aged 87; father N. J. Harsh, mother Louise Martin. 1920 census (ED 227, sheet 6A, lines 42–43, 13–15 January 1920): Albert Timberman, 26, born Pennsylvania, father born New Jersey, mother Pennsylvania, no occupation (a small raised middle initial reads M but could be N); Nancy, his wife, 25, born Tennessee, both parents born Tennessee; a rented apartment at 109 North Franklin Street, Wilkes-Barre Ward 4, in a house of nine households. No maiden name is on the sheet.
- S1990Long, Gen. Griffith Rutherford and Allied Families, p. 176 — Nancy May Harsh. Ancestry, record 4440719239. Read from the image in the Stage 2 reading, 14 October 2026. Probable Compiled family history. Nancy May, born 7 January 1894; Howard College, Gallatin, 1912; married at home 1 December 1918 Albert Timberman of Wilkes-Barre, army officer in the First World War; lived Wilkes-Barre and New York; no children.
- S2272Find a Grave memorial 129937918 — George Harsh, Gallatin City Cemetery, Sumner County, Tennessee. Findagrave.com, read 7 October 2026 (memorial page). A volunteer’s compiled page, not an original record. Probable Born 24 April 1827, Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania; died 26 June 1895, Castalian Springs; wife Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds (1849–1925), married 1878, given as the second. The page transcribes a county-history sketch naming his parents as “Phillip and Madeline (Kahler) Harsh” and the Nashville Banner and Tennessean notices of 27–29 June 1895. Parents linked: Dr Philip Harsh (born May 1797, Oppenheim; died 27 July 1870, Nashville) and Magdalena Kehler (1802–1883). It agrees with the 1870 and 1880 census households (S504, S588, S1311) on George’s age, birthplace and father’s German birthplace. The sketch itself, now read (S2276), names three wives, so Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds was the third. What it does not settle: the newspapers were not read by us; Dr Harsh’s own dates are only possible.
- S2274Find a Grave memorials 94179857 and 94180352 — Elizabeth Caroline Harsh Chenault and Philip Harsh Chenault, Rose Hill Burial Park, Oklahoma City. Findagrave.com, read 7 October 2026 (memorial pages). Volunteers’ compiled pages, not original records. Probable Elizabeth Caroline Harsh Chenault: born 24 July 1865, Sumner County, Tennessee; died 19 June 1948, Oklahoma City. Husband linked: Colby Burris Chenault (8 August 1863 – 23 July 1955), married 1886. Father linked: George Harsh. Children linked: Georgie Tabitha (Thomas) (1890–1930), Will Kirk (Carr) (1894–1965) and Philip Harsh Chenault (3 February 1909 – 31 October 1970). Her age agrees with Caroline, 5, and Callie, 14, in George Harsh’s 1870 and 1880 households (S504, S588), and her husband’s with Colby Jr., son, 16, in Colby B. Chenault’s 1880 household. What it does not settle: no death record of either was read (their licence is S2286; the 1910 and 1940 censuses, S2308 and S2310, place them in Muskogee and Oklahoma City), the exact birth and death days are on these pages alone, and the memorial links her to her stepmother Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds, who married George in 1878, after her birth; the 1887 sketch (S2276) lists “Callie E.” among Talitha Newby’s children.
- S2276Goodspeed Publishing Co., History of Tennessee (Nashville, 1887), Sumner County biographies — sketch “Capt. Geo. Harsh”. Read 7 October 2026 as the Sumner County TNGenWeb transcription (retyped by a volunteer, 1999–2001), from the Internet Archive’s 2005 capture of rootsweb.com/~tnsumner/fahars.htm; the live page is gone; not the printed page. Probable George Harsh, son of Phillip and Madeline (Kahler) Harsh, born in Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania, in 1827; in 1851 he married Mary S. O. Guthrie, who died in 1855; in 1856 Miss “Tobithia” Newby of Smith County, by whom ten children, eight living: Phillip W., Mary A. (Mrs. W. W. Brown), Nathan J., Callie E., Lee Cheatham, George, R. N. Herbert and William G.; then Mrs. James K. Polk, daughter of William T. and Mary A. Edmonds of Memphis, by whom Thomas Walker and Alex Cyrus. A compiled county history, written from the family’s account in his lifetime. It agrees with Nathan’s death certificate (S503) on his mother and with the 1870 and 1880 households (S504, S588). It prints the second wife’s death as 1868 and the third marriage as 1869, which conflict with its own statement that Mrs. Polk first married in 1871 and with the 1870 household; the Find a Grave dates (died 9 December 1877; married 1878) are the better reading. No marriage record has been read.
- S2286Sumner County, Tennessee, marriage licence, C. B. Chenault and Callie E. Harsh, 23 December 1886. Read from the image (Ancestry, Tennessee State Marriages). Confirmed The licence is dated 23 December 1886. The minister’s return is not on the image, so the wedding day itself is not shown; the index’s “marriage date” is the licence date.
- S23081910 U.S. census, Muskogee, Oklahoma, household of C. B. Chenault. Ancestry record 153279899. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0440, 19 Oct 2026). Confirmed C. B., 46, retail furniture dealer, and Callie E., 44, married 23 years, eight children born, seven living; Georgia T., Jodie D., Wil K., Haynie, Margaret M., Frances L., 7, and Phillip H. Wil K. is marked daughter here, son (William K.) in 1900; not settled.
- S23091920 U.S. census, Gallatin, Sumner County, Tennessee, household of Colby B. Chenault. Ancestry record 36257998. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0440, 19 Oct 2026). Confirmed Colby B., 56, real-estate agent; Callie, 54; Margaret, 19; Fanny, 17; Phillip H., 10. Their son Charles H., 22, and his wife Vera on the next line.
- S23101940 U.S. census, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, household of C. B. Chenault. Ancestry record 86062850. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0440, 19 Oct 2026). Confirmed C. B., 76; Callie; Philip H., 31; living in the same house in 1935. Callie’s age is faint on the image; the indexed “about 1862” is not used.
- S2312Harsh family history, p. 176: Callie Harsh, daughter of George Harsh and Talitha Newby. Ancestry record 4295225219 (book page). Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0440, 19 Oct 2026). Probable Fourth child; “born April 1865 at Rose Cottage near Nashville”; married Colby Chenault December 1886. A compiled family account. Its April 1865 disagrees with July 1865 in the 1900 census (S2287) and 24 July 1865 on her memorial (S2274); the card keeps 24 July.
- S23531860 U.S. census, 23rd District, Davidson County, Tennessee (P.O. Goodlettsville), household of Geo Harsh. Ancestry record 19050682. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0440, 19 Oct 2026). Confirmed Geo Harsh, 32, farmer, born in Pennsylvania; Mrs T., 25; Philip, 3; Mary, 1; Miss Guthrie, 18.
- S2384Tennessee death certificate no. 22050, Thomas Walker Harsh, Memphis, 6 October 1946. Ancestry record 16112949. Read from the image (Stage 2 batch 1019-0655, 19 Oct 2026). Confirmed Born 16 September 1879 at Gallatin; a retired criminal-court judge; father George Harsh, mother Elizabeth Kirk Edmonds; wife Mary Read Harsh; buried in Elmwood Cemetery. Ancestry’s index reads the surname as “Harck”. The parents are given by an informant.
- S3495Meyers Gazetteer of the German Empire (Meyers Orts- und Verkehrs-Lexikon, 1912), vol. 2, p. 406: Offenheim. Online edition, meyersgaz.org/place/20406010, read 7 November 2026 (NP11-1107E). Two places named Offenheim: one in Kreis Strassburg, Unter-Elsass (20406009), and Offenheim in Kreis Alzey, Rheinhessen, Hessen (20406010), a village with its own Standesamt and one Protestant parish church, 541 people, Amtsgericht Alzey. It shows that the “Offenheim” of the 1880 census is a real Rheinhessen village. It does not show whether Dr Philip Harsh came from there or from Oppenheim. Serves the cards of George Harsh and Louise Bell Martin Harsh.
Know something this page doesn't? Send it to Earl — corrections, names, dates, documents. Nothing appears here until he has reviewed it.
