The Proeger Family · Generation 7 — Kristin's 4th-great-grandparents

John Caffey Sr.

Probable father of Charles Caffey · 1751–1826

John Caffey Sr.

MarylandProbable

Probable father of Charles Caffey · 1751–1826

Born
1751
Died
19 August 1826
Buried
in Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery
Children
Charles Caffey, Sarah Eugenia Caffey Hardwick
Sources
15
Images
5

Research status

Research status: PROBABLE — accepted by Earl 28 September 2026 pending more evidence. His will, dated 2 August 1821 and read from the original Montgomery County will book, divides his personal estate among “my Seven Children (Viz) Thomas Caffey Elizabeth Caffey Henry Caffey Michael Caffey John Caffey Charles Caffey and Hooper Caffey” S848, and in 1850 Charles, 61, born North Carolina, lived in Montgomery County beside Thomas, 66, and Michael, 68, two more of the named sons S484. What is weak: no record pins the will's Charles as this Charles; the will gives no ages or residences Probable confirm or correct →

Evidence: John Caffey's 1821 will, read from the original Montgomery County will book, names seven children including Charles; in 1850 Charles, 61, lived beside Thomas and Michael, two more of the named sons. Weak or missing: No record pins the will's Charles as this Charles: the will gives no ages or residences, and the 1850 census states no relationships. Not yet confirmed. Know more? Confirm or correct this →

Life in the order the records give it

John Caffey Sr. is the probable father of Charles Caffey. A 1923 Sons of the American Revolution application, a compiled lineage paper, gives his birth in 1751 in Dorchester County, Maryland, his marriage about 1780 to Mary Buchanan, and his death on 19 August 1826 in Montgomery County, Alabama S849. His headstone at Montgomery reads 1751–1826, and the Alabama Journal reported his death S61. A DAR lineage book, which gives his birth as 1752 against the headstone’s 1751, says he enlisted in 1776 in the Maryland Line, but it cites nothing, and the service is unproven S1073. His will, dated 2 August 1821 and probated 22 August 1826, leaves “my Loving wife Sarah Caffey” the quarter section he lived on. It also leaves her, for her life, the enslaved man Jordan, the enslaved woman Rachael and her son Ems S848S61. It divides his personal estate among “my Seven Children”: Thomas, Elizabeth, Henry, Michael, John, Charles and Hooper S848. In 1850 Charles, 61, lived in Montgomery County beside Thomas and Michael S484. The will gives no ages or residences, so the link to this Charles is graded Probable. He is buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery, by grave indexes, and that too is graded Probable S2449. His father was probably John Caffe of Guilford County, North Carolina (d. 1783), whose will of 19 July 1783 names a son John and makes him an executor; the estate file calls him “John Caffy Juner Executor of John Caffy Siner Deceased” S3587S3588. Michael Caffey (d. 1754, Dorchester County, Maryland) may be his grandfather; no record names the relationship S3584S3585.

Record1821
His will, dated 2 August 1821 and probated 22 August 1826, leaves “my Loving wife Sarah Caffey” the quarter section he lived on, the north-west quarter of section 28, township 16, range 18, and for her life the enslaved man Jordan, the enslaved woman Rachael and her son Ems; after her death the land goes to his son Hooper Caffey S848S61
Birth1751
Born 1751, Dorchester County, Maryland, and died 19 August 1826, Montgomery County, Alabama, by a 1923 Sons of the American Revolution application, a compiled lineage paper, which gives his wife as Mary Buchanan, married about 1780 S849; his headstone at Montgomery reads 1751–1826 and the Alabama Journal reported his death S61. He is buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery, by two BillionGraves rows and the Find a Grave index (Probable: index only, and the cemetery name is on no image read) S2449. An online tree's middle name “Thomas” is on no record read, and its “Cambridge” and “Ramer” come only from compiled indexes and Find a Grave
Burial1752
Two compiled papers agree with his will and headstone. A typescript family chart in the Alabama Surname Files gives John Caffey, born near Cambridge, Dorchester County, Maryland, 1752, married about 1780 Mary Buchanan, died Montgomery County 19 August 1826, with children Henry, Michael, Thomas (born 24 May 1784), John (born 29 September 1786), Charles (born 1788), Hooper (born 1 November 1793) and Nancy S1072. A DAR Lineage Book (page 185, member 116597) says John Caffey (1752–1826), born in Maryland, enlisted in 1776 in the 6th company, Maryland Line, and died at Montgomery, and runs a line through his son William Hooper Caffey (1793–1835) S1073. Evidence: the names, places and death date match the will S848 and headstone S61. Weak: both are late compilations that cite nothing on the page; the children’s birth dates and the war service are unproven, the chart names a Nancy and not the will’s Elizabeth, and the headstone’s 1751 stands against their 1752. Know more? Use “Add to this record”.

Family parents, marriages, children, siblings

Parents1783
Father: probably John Caffe of Guilford County, North Carolina (d. 1783). His will of 19 July 1783, read from the image, names a son John Caffe and makes sons John and Thomas executors S3587; his estate file calls the executor “John Caffy Juner Executor of John Caffy Siner Deceased” S3588. A “John Caffey jun.” carried the chain on the father’s Haw River survey of 29 May 1782 S3596, and on 2 August 1783 the father deeded 110 acres on the south side of Haw River to “John Coffee junior” S3595. What is weak: no single record names both the Guilford son John and the Alabama will-maker of 1821, and the 1923 application’s Dorchester birth is not tied to the Guilford family by any record read. Michael Caffey (d. 1754, Dorchester County, Maryland), once given as his father, is probably not: an adult John Caffee signed Michael’s 1754 inventory as next of kin S3585, and Michael may be his grandfather (Possible). Probable confirm or correct →
Children1895
His son Hooper probably left a daughter at Montgomery. The Birmingham Age-Herald of 12 July 1895 reported the death there of Mrs Hardwick, about 70, mother of Mrs C. L. Ruth, S. H. Hardwick of Atlanta and J. C. Hardwick of Birmingham, “a daughter of the late Hooper Caffey, one of the first editors of the Montgomery Advertiser” S3488. That this Hooper is John’s son, William Hooper Caffey (1793–1835) S1073, is Probable: the name, the town and the years fit, but the paper is a single late statement and does not name his father. Her name was probably Sarah Eugenia Caffey Hardwick: a Find a Grave memorial gives her as born on 6 January 1824 in Alabama and died on 11 July 1895, buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery (Scott’s Free Ground), the wife of William Henry Hardwick Sr (1808–1854), with children including John Clark Hardwick (1843–1891), Juliette Hardwick Ruth (1844–1917) and Samuel Henry Hardwick (1854–1918), the three mourners named in the notice S3489 Probable. The date, the town, her age and the three children all agree with the paper; weak: the memorial is compiled, and its gravestone photo has not been read. Know more? Confirm or correct this →
Parents2026
History of this card. 19 Nov 2026
father link set to John Caffe of Guilford County (d. 1783), Probable, from his will and estate file (S3587, S3588), the 1782 survey (S3596) and the 1783 deed (S3595); the card had named no father, and the line page had given Michael Caffey as his father. SWEEP-1119J.
7 Nov 2026 — Mrs Hardwick’s name, Sarah Eugenia Caffey Hardwick (1824–1895), added from Find a Grave memorial 90746654 (S3489), Probable; the sentence that said her given name was not known is replaced. NP11-1107D, SWEEP-1107H.
7 Nov 2026 — the 1895 Age-Herald notice of Hooper Caffey’s daughter Mrs Hardwick added (S3488), Probable; no grade on this card changed. NP11-1107B, SWEEP-1107G.
The notes on this card that carried a “new” mark were added on these days: 29 Sep 2026 (1 note). The marks and their dates were taken off on 12 Oct 2026, and nothing in the notes was changed. 25 Oct 2026 — burial in Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery, added from the BillionGraves and Find a Grave indexes (S2449), Probable; written to the Ancestry tree the same day.
Children1789
Father of Charles Caffey, born 1789 S663.

Open questions what is probable, weak or missing — confirm or correct it

Probable
Probable father of Charles Caffey

Photos & documents 0 portraits · 0 photos · 5 documents

Documents (5)

Documents · 5 page images all documents

Retrieved from FamilySearch. Any other image names its source in its own entry. Each thumbnail opens the full image, which can also be downloaded. The quoted text is a reading of the handwritten page, with an English translation where the record is not in English; the image is the authority.

Page survey of Guilford County, N.C., land warrants and surveys; FamilySearch "North Carolina, Wills and Deeds", ark 3:1:3QS7-89WK-38T · S3596, 29 May 1782

John Caffe — Guilford County, N.C., land warrants and surveys; FamilySearch "North Carolina, Wills and Deeds", ark 3:1:3QS7-89WK-38T · S3596 — page survey

Land survey · 29 May 1782

State of North Carolina. Plotted by a Scale of 100[?] Poles in an Inch. The annexed Plan represents 240 Acres of Land Surveyed for John Caffey the 29th May 1782 Situate on both sides of Haw River in the County of Guilford. Beginning at his own corner Maple in the lowground in the Crook or bent of said River in George Rowlands line running thence along his line South crossing said River twice one hundred & thirty two poles to the Claimants own corner Grub the …
Page file 046 of Guilford County, N.C., wills, file no. 046 (register copy); FamilySearch ark 3:1:939L-V1S2-6P · S3587, 19 July 1783

John Caffe — Guilford County, N.C., wills, file no. 046 (register copy); FamilySearch ark 3:1:939L-V1S2-6P · S3587 — page file 046

Will (register copy) · 19 July 1783

In the name of God amen. I John Caffe of the County of Guilford in the State of North Carolina being of sound and perfect mind memory and understanding … do this nineteenth day of July in the year of Christ 1783 make and publish this my last will and testament … First I desire that all my just debts and funeral charges be paid. Secondly I give and devise unto my beloved children Michael Caffe, Elizabeth Milford, Nancy Bell, John Caffe, Sophia Baines, Sarah Beach, Mary Simon[?] and Rebeccah Norman each one shilling Sterling. Thirdly I give and devise unto my beloved son Thomas Caffe all the tract of land and plantation whereon I now …
Page Bk 2 p. 429 of Guilford County, N.C., Deed Book 2, p. 429; FamilySearch "North Carolina, Wills and Deeds", ark 3:1:3QS7-L98T-2QP · S3595, 2 August 1783

John Caffe — Guilford County, N.C., Deed Book 2, p. 429; FamilySearch "North Carolina, Wills and Deeds", ark 3:1:3QS7-L98T-2QP · S3595 — page Bk 2 p. 429

Deed · 2 August 1783

429 John Coffee to John Coffee jun.r. This Indenture made the 2[nd] Day of August in the year of Christ 1783 Between John Coffee of the County of Guilford in the State of North Carolina of the one part and John Coffee jun.r of the County and State aforesaid of the other part Witnesseth that for and in consideration of the sum of five pounds Specia[l] … paid … hath granted bargained sold … unto the said John Coffee Jun.r his heirs and assigns all that piece Parcel or tract of Land lying & being on the South Side of Haw River in the aforesaid County of Guilford Beginning … on the South bank of said River in George Rowland's line … con …

Documents and record images for the Caffey family →

John Caffey Sr. · Sources

Citations

Sources cited on this card

15 of the record's sources are cited here. The numbering is the record's own; the full list, with where else each is cited, is at Sources.

  1. S61John Caffey Sr (1751–1826), three items: a typed abstract of the will-book page (p. 110) recording his will dated 2 Aug 1821 and probated 22 Aug 1826, naming wife Sarah and children Thomas, Elizabeth, Henry, Michael, John, Charles and Hooper; his headstone at Montgomery, Alabama, photographed 2010; and his obituary in the Montgomery Alabama Journal, August 1826, recording Revolutionary War service. The will is an abstract, not the original — one step off the record; the same abstract page carries two unrelated wills. These three documents establish the man. They do not establish his descent to Kristin, which rests on S57 alone — see the note on that link.
  2. S4841850 U.S. Federal Census — Charles Caffey household, 2nd District, Montgomery County, Alabama, p. 152. Ancestry record 15675750. Image examined, read 25 September 2026. Confirmed Dwelling 19: Charles Caffey, 61, born North Carolina, farmer; Nancy, 59, born North Carolina; Elizabeth J., 22; Hooper V., 17, born Alabama, farmer. Thomas (66), Michael (68) and Lindsey R. Caffey (34), all born North Carolina, live within four dwellings. The 1850 census names no relationships, so this is co-residence, not proof that Charles was Hooper's father. It is the first record for that link.
  3. S848Will of John Caffey, Montgomery County, Alabama, dated 2 August 1821 — original will-book entry, item 99, page stamped 35. Ancestry collection 8799, record 2448490 (image 007651670_00810). Image examined, read 28 September 2026. Probable “I John Caffey of the County of Montgomery and State of Alabama … unto my Loving wife Sarah Caffey the quarter Section of Land whereon I now Live being the North west quarter of number twenty Eight in Township Sixteen and Range Eighteen”; the enslaved man Jordan, the enslaved woman Rachael and her son Ems to his wife for life; the land afterwards to “my Son Hooper Caffey”; the personal estate “Equally divided amongst my Seven Children (Viz) Thomas Caffey Elizabeth Caffey Henry Caffey Michael Caffey John Caffey Charles Caffey and Hooper Caffey”. The original book entry behind the abstract in S61; it agrees with the abstract. It gives no ages or residences for the children, so it does not by itself show that its Charles is Charles Caffey (c. 1789–1860).
  4. S849Sons of the American Revolution supplemental application, National no. 24618 (Illinois no. 2368), William Gorin Smith, approved 31 January 1923. Ancestry collection 2204, record 417410 (image 32596_242191-00051). Image examined, read 28 September 2026 and again 13 October 2026. Probable John Caffey, born 1751, Dorchester County, Maryland; died 19 August 1826, Montgomery, Alabama; wife Mary Buchanan, married about 1780; descent through Thomas Caffey (1784–1878) and Mary B. Patrick. A compiled lineage paper, not an original record. Line 6, for John’s parents, is left blank. Charles is not named. Two more SAR applications (31209 and 30985, 1918), seen only in an index, also name Mary Buchanan but give death years of 1737 and 1837.
  5. S1072Alabama, U.S., Surname Files Expanded, 1702–1981 — typescript family compilation, page “-6-”, section “Great-great-great-great grandparents of Gordon”, entry 80G. Ancestry record 145642. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Confirmed A compiled chart, not an original record: 80G John Caffey, born near Cambridge, Dorchester County, Maryland, 1752; married about 1780 81G Mary Buchanan; died Montgomery County, Alabama, 19 August 1826. Children: Henry; Michael, born about 1784; Thomas, born 24 May 1784; John, born 29 September 1786; Charles, born 1788; Hooper, born 1 November 1793; Nancy. The same man as the will (S848) and headstone (S61). A late derivative that cites nothing on the page: the children’s birth dates are the compiler’s, it names a Nancy and no Elizabeth, and its 1752 stands against the headstone’s 1751.
  6. S1073North America, Family Histories, 1500–2000 — DAR Lineage Book, page 185, Mrs. Algie Hardwick Hill, member 116597 (volume number not on the image). Ancestry record 3534392. Image examined in the Stage 2 reading, 29 September 2026. Confirmed Mrs. Algie Hardwick Hill, born New York, wife of Walton H. Hill, descends from John Caffey through Samuel Henry Hardwick (b. 1854), William Hardwick (1808–54) and Sarah Eugenia Caffey (1824–96), and William Hooper Caffey (1793–1835), who married — Shellcott, son of John Caffey and Mary Buchanan. “John Caffey (1752–1826) enlisted, 1776, in 6th company, Maryland Line. He was born in Maryland; died in Montgomery, Ala. Also No. 108176.” The same man as the will (S848). A DAR lineage entry of this period prints no sources; the war service is the society’s accepted claim, not a muster roll.
  7. S2449BillionGraves and Find a Grave indexes — John Caffey Sr., Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery, Alabama. FamilySearch indexes, searched 23 September 2026 (Stage 5 b33). Index entries only — no image or memorial photograph was examined. Probable Two BillionGraves rows: John Caffey, 1751 – 19 August 1826, Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery. Find a Grave index: John Caffey, Sr., born 1751, died 19 August 1826, burial Montgomery. The headstone photograph of 2010 (S61) shows the dates but its cemetery is not named on the item read. The burial date is not known.
  8. S3488Birmingham (Alabama) Age-Herald, 12 July 1895, p. 1, Montgomery column: death of Mrs Hardwick. Chronicling America, Library of Congress, sn84020639/1895-07-12/ed-1. Read from the page text, 7 November 2026 (NP11-1107B). Mrs Hardwick, about 70, died at Montgomery; she was the mother of Mrs C. L. Ruth, S. H. Hardwick of Atlanta and J. C. Hardwick of Birmingham, and “a daughter of the late Hooper Caffey, one of the first editors of the Montgomery Advertiser”. It is a single late statement. It fails to give her given name, which Find a Grave supplies (S3489), and it does not itself say that this Hooper was the son of John Caffey Sr. Serves the card of John Caffey Sr.
  9. S3489Find a Grave, memorial 90746654: Sarah Eugenia Caffey Hardwick (1824–1895), Oakwood Cemetery, Montgomery, Montgomery County, Alabama (Scott’s Free Ground). findagrave.com. Read 7 November 2026 (NP11-1107D). Born 6 January 1824 in Alabama, died 11 July 1895; parent link Hooper Caffey (1793–1835); spouse William Henry Hardwick Sr (1808–1854); children John Clark (1843–1891), Juliette Hardwick Ruth (1844–1917), William Henry Jr (1846–1862), Andrew Caffey (1849–1886), Benjamin M. (1852–1861) and Samuel Henry (1854–1918); siblings listed as Nancy Ann Caffey Spear, Elizabeth “Eliza” Caffey Adams, John Hooper Caffee and Andrew Jackson Caffey. It gives the given name and dates that S3488 lacks, and its death date and three of its children match that notice. It is compiled: the family links are not documented on the page, and the gravestone photo has not been read. Serves the card of John Caffey Sr.
  10. S3584Will of Michael Caffey, Dorchester County, Maryland, 16 February 1754, proved 2 March 1754. Md. Prerogative Court Wills Liber 29, pp. 142–143; FHL film 12852 (DGS 7737524) image 310, FamilySearch ark 3:1:3Q9M-C91H-W7KJ. Image read 19 November 2026. Confirmed All personal estate to “my Loving Wife Sarah Caffey”, sole executrix; witnesses Rachel Layton and Ann Baker; Michael signed by mark (“Coffee”). Names no children.
  11. S3585Inventory of Michael Caffey, Dorchester, appraised 4 May 1754, sworn 27 January 1755. Md. Prerogative Court Inventories vol. 60, pp. 75–77; FHL film 12880 (DGS 7541731) images 40–41, arks 3:1:3QS7-9981-W7B8-G and 3:1:3QS7-9981-W7BX-D. Images read 19 November 2026. Confirmed Sworn by the widow Sarah; next of kin “Jno [his mark] Caffee” and “Jno Bestpitch”. The adult John was grown by 1754 and cannot be John Caffey Sr, born 1751; the inventory states no relationship.
  12. S3587Will of John Caffe, Guilford County, North Carolina, 19 July 1783. Guilford County wills, file no. 046 (register copy); FamilySearch ark 3:1:939L-V1S2-6P. Image read 19 November 2026. Confirmed Names children Michael Caffe, Elizabeth Milford, Nancy Bell, John Caffe, Sophia Baines, Sarah Beach, Mary Simon[?] and Rebeccah Norman; son Thomas the home plantation; executors sons John and Thomas. That his son John is John Caffey Sr of Alabama is Probable: no single record names both.
  13. S3588Estate file of John Caffey (Senr), Guilford County, 1785–1791. “North Carolina, Estate Files, 1663–1979”, FHL DGS 7641359 images 453–474, index ark 1:1:Q2Z7-3J1R. Images read 19 November 2026. Confirmed Calls the executor “John Caffy Juner Executor of John Caffy Siner Deceased” (February 1785); widow Nancy Caffe; executor’s account returned February Term 1791. Does not name John junior’s later residence.
  14. S3595Deed, John Coffee to John Coffee junior, Guilford County, North Carolina, 2 August 1783. Guilford County Deed Book 2, p. 429, FamilySearch “North Carolina, Wills and Deeds”, ark 3:1:3QS7-L98T-2QP. Image read 19 November 2026. Confirmed 110 acres on the south side of Haw River to “John Coffee junior” for £5; witnesses Michael and Thomas Coffey. States no relationship; the will of 19 July 1783 (S3587) names sons John, Michael and Thomas.
  15. S3596Survey of 240 acres for John Caffey, both sides of Haw River, Guilford County, North Carolina, 29 May 1782. Guilford County land warrants and surveys, FamilySearch “North Carolina, Wills and Deeds”, ark 3:1:3QS7-89WK-38T. Image read 19 November 2026. Confirmed Begins “at his own corner”; chain carriers Robert Rowland and “John Caffey jun.”; surveyor Charles Bruce. Shows an elder and a younger John Caffey on the same Haw River land in 1782.

Know something this page doesn't? Send it to Earl — corrections, names, dates, documents. Nothing appears here until he has reviewed it.

Compiled for the Proeger family

Living adults appear by name and relationship, with the year only: no full date of birth and no home town on any page that search engines index, and a living person’s own page is kept out of search engines. Minors appear by name only — no date of birth, no birth year, no age, no school, no place, no address, no other identifying detail. A minor may be named and may appear in a family photograph; nothing further about them is published. Where it is not established whether someone is an adult or a minor, the minor rule applies.

Know something this record doesn't? Send it to Earl.

Top