The Proeger Family · DNA evidence
What the DNA says
Earl's own DNA results, set beside the paper record. Aggregate percentages only; no living relative is named.
On this page
On this page
Whose family are you here for?
Showing both families — every line on the page. Pick a side to hide the other family's ancestors; Earl, Kristin and their three children stay on either way.
DNA · What the DNA says
The record
- HHomethe fan · what changed · open questions
- MMigrationbirths and deaths on a map, by decade
- TTimeline1539 entries · 5 eras
- PPeople571 people, by generation
- LLines13 surname pages
The evidence
The findings
How to read this record
Every claim is tagged
Most family trees flatten everything into the same confident typeface. This one does not. The three research tags below are the whole point of the exercise: they say what a document proves, what the weight of evidence suggests, and what nobody has found yet. A fourth marks what the family stated directly, where no document has been retrieved at all — it is kept separate on purpose and is never quietly promoted to confirmed. A fifth marks biological evidence: a DNA result is not a document, and it is not testimony either. Two further labels mark where this page withholds information rather than lacking it.
Attested by a document that was actually retrieved and read — a census sheet, a government index, a grave marker, a family-written obituary.
Strongly supported but not nailed down: a user-contributed tree, a masked index field, or a chain of consistent circumstances. Believable, not proven.
Searched for and not located. This is a statement about the search, not about the person — the record may well exist somewhere unsearched.
Supplied by the family and recorded on their word — no document has been retrieved for it. Note the diamond rather than the dot: this is provenance, not proof, and it stands apart from the three record tags above S24.
Biological evidence consistent with a claim. It corroborates origins; it does not by itself establish a person or a link. Note the bar rather than a dot or a diamond: no DNA result on this page is ever counted as confirmed, because no document was read for it S46.
The person is living. On the charts and in the chains of names a living person appears by name and relationship. A living adult’s full record is on their own card, published with the family’s consent and kept out of search engines. A minor appears by name only. The privacy note at the head of the page gives the rule in full.
A branch that is actively being worked on. The node exists in the structure so the shape of the family is honest; the detail is simply not in yet.
What the DNA says · Earl's side
Independent evidence
What the DNA says
Everything else in this record is paper. On 13 September 2026 a different kind of evidence arrived: Earl's own autosomal ancestry results DNA evidence S46. It is set apart deliberately. A DNA percentage is not a document and cannot be confirmed on this page's meaning of the word — nobody retrieved and read a record. What it can do is test the shape of the tree from outside the archive, and on one question it did exactly that — a day before the records caught up with it.
AncestryDNA — three relatives' tests are in; Earl's own kit is not
Three relatives have shared their AncestryDNA tests with this research, and each was read against this tree:
- A brother of Earl (2017 test, shared 12 October 2026). A full brother carries the same ancestors as Earl, so his matches test both of Earl's sides.
- A brother of Earl's mother (read 13 October 2026). His matches test the mother's side only (Coffman, Timberman, Martin, Bowles, Brock, Howard, Wright), one generation closer to those ancestors.
- A first cousin of Earl on his father's side (read 15 October 2026). She shares only the Proeger, Silva, Rose and Roberts ancestors with Earl; her other side is an unrelated family.
The brother's raw data was also uploaded to GEDmatch and FamilyTreeDNA. The GEDmatch list was still processing when last checked on 12 October 2026, and nothing on this page draws on it. Of the FamilyTreeDNA list, only the strongest Bowles match has been read. MyHeritage no longer accepts uploads, so it is not used. The results below are counts only.
Earl's own AncestryDNA kit, ordered on 8 October 2026, has not come back. A kit takes weeks from the day the sample is mailed, and it must be activated by its owner before it can be linked to this tree. A second kit was ordered for a relative on the Walker side, who would cover the Walker side and the lines that come down through it. The Caffey line is not on the Walker side and needs a Caffey-side relative to test. As with the 23andMe match list below, no AncestryDNA match will be named here.
What a brother's matches support so far (12 October 2026)
Method. A full brother carries the same ancestors as Earl. For each ancestral couple we count the matches whose own published trees descend from that couple. All 299 of the strongest match pages have now been read; 252 of them show a common-ancestor couple beyond the immediate family (two more are the tester's own brothers). Each match is counted once, under the couple its page names, so the counts add up to a number of people. "One partner only" means the page names that person alone.
Two kinds of couple. Most couples below are people who are in our own tree. Others are Ancestry-suggested ("potential ancestor") couples: Ancestry has stitched them in from other members' trees, so they are hypotheses resting on other people's trees, and they are marked suggested. Other people's trees are leads, not evidence. "DNA-supported" below means only that matches descend from that couple by their own trees. It does not change the status of any card on this site. Generations are counted from Earl's own generation.
Father's side (Proeger, Silva, Rose, Roberts) — couples in our own tree
- William Harry Proeger × Aileane Marie Silva — grandparents — 3 matches
- William Leonard Proeger (1876–1955) × Anna Blanche Roberts — great-grandparents — 7
- Antone Rose × Louise Rose — great-great-grandparents — 5
- Henry S. Roberts × Rose Alice Williams — great-great-grandparents — 1
- Thomás Pereira d'Escobar × Anna Luiza do Coração de Jesus — 3× great-grandparents — 5
- José Francisco da Silva × Florência Luiza — 3× great-grandparents — 3, from two independent families; they are the parents of Frank Silva Sr
- Elisabethe Sabina Lösch (one partner only) — 3× great-grandparent — 1; the mother of Julius Karl Proeger
Father's side — Ancestry-suggested couples (hypotheses)
- Henry Roberts × Harriet — 3× great-grandparents — 2, suggested; the paper record now confirms Harriet as Henry S. Roberts’s mother and makes Henry his probable father (Henry Roberts, Harriet Roberts)
- António Dutra de Mendonça × Luísa Feliciana Bulcão — 4× great-grandparents — 4, suggested (two name the couple, two name her alone); they would be on Louise Rose's line if right
- Gabriel José Pereira Moitoso × Elísia Rosa Duarte da Silveira — 5× great-grandparents — 2, suggested; Escobar side
- Francisco Silveira de Medeiros (one partner only) — 5× great-grandparent — 2, suggested; Azorean, line not identified
Mother's side (Coffman, Timberman, Martin, Bowles, Brock, Howard, Wright) — couples in our own tree
- Louise Martin Timberman × Robert William Coffman — grandparents — 1 match
- James David Coffman × Lydia Mae Bowles — great-grandparents — 5
- Iona Belle Brock × William Anderson Bowles — great-great-grandparents — 11 (one of them names him alone)
- David Emily Coffman × Mary Jane Wright — great-great-grandparents — 10
- Joseph Daniel Martin × Nancy "Nannie" Chenault — great-great-grandparents — 2
- James Harris Timberman × Louise E. Harbauer — great-great-grandparents — 1
- James Daniel Bowles × Lydia Williams — 3× great-grandparents — 23
- Solomon Alfred Brock × Matilda Pauline Howard — 3× great-grandparents — 12
- Ludwig Harbauer × Eva — 3× great-grandparents — 2
- David C. Coffman × Emily M. Thornhill — 3× great-grandparents — 1
- James W. Wright × Lucy Brooks — 3× great-grandparents — 1
- David Chenault × Louisa Quisenberry — 3× great-grandparents — 1
- John Covey Howard × Matilda Brock — 4× great-grandparents — 44 (one of them names him alone)
- Elizabeth Howard (one partner only) — 4× great-grandparent — 33, no husband given
- Moses Williams × Nancy — 4× great-grandparents — 11
- William A. Bowles × Lucy Ann Thomas — 4× great-grandparents — 7 (five of them name her alone)
- Thomas Wright × Martha Ann Tate — 4× great-grandparents — 3
- Nancy Tait (one partner only) — 4× great-grandparent — 3
- Lucy Bush (one partner only) — 4× great-grandparent — 1
- John Howard × Mary Risner — 5× great-grandparents — 35 (one of them names him alone)
- James Wilder × Nancy Hays — 5× great-grandparents — 1
Mother's side — Ancestry-suggested couples (hypotheses)
- John Martin × Sarah Hines — 4× great-grandparents — 1; she is suggested. They would be the parents of Peter Hines Martin if right
- James Calvin Brock × Elizabeth "Betsy" Osbourne — 5× great-grandparents — 2
- Robert Lee Tate × Martha "Patsy" Brewer — 5× great-grandparents — 2
- William Chenault × Elizabeth Jane Mullins — 5× great-grandparents — 2 (one of them names him alone)
- John Hines (Haines) × Sarah Elizabeth Barham — 5× great-grandparents — 1
- Thomas W. Thornhill × Lucy Jane Jones — 5× great-grandparents — 1; Emily Thornhill's side
Deepest generation with any match, by line: Proeger — great-grandparents (plus the single Lösch match one step beyond the immigrant); Roberts — 3× great (suggested); Silva and Escobar — 3× great in our tree, 5× great suggested; Rose — 2× great in our tree, 4× great suggested; Coffman — 3× great; Wright — 4× great; Bowles, Brock, Howard — 5× great; Timberman and Harbauer — 3× great; Martin and Chenault — 3× great in our tree, 5× great suggested.
What the DNA now says about the open questions
- Silva parents — now corroborated. Three matches, from two independent families, descend from José Francisco da Silva × Florência Luiza through a child other than Frank Silva Sr; one family's tree comes down from a daughter born about 1865. The parents were already Confirmed from Frank Sr's 1862 baptism at Cedros, Faial; the DNA agrees from outside the archive and proposes no new parents.
- Coffman, up to David C. — now well supported. In the uncle's kit seven matches, each with its own tree manager, descend from David C. Coffman × Emily M. Thornhill through at least three of their children (the brother's kit had one). That agrees with a link already held as Confirmed; the card is unchanged.
- Samuel Coffman — first DNA at his level. One match in the uncle's kit descends from Samuel Coffman through his daughter Elizabeth (Mrs. Grayson), the sister of David C. named among Samuel's heirs in the Page County chancery papers. It fits the paper. The match is far stronger than a fourth cousin would normally be and has a second Page County line, so it shows our Coffmans belong to the Page County Kaufman families rather than measuring the Samuel link alone. It says nothing about Samuel's wife.
- Matilda Pauline Howard's parents — strongly supported. In the uncle's kit 44 matches, from 44 different tree managers and through at least seven of their children, descend from John Covey Howard × Matilda Brock, the couple already in this tree.
- Solomon Alfred Brock's parents — the DNA agrees with the paper. In the uncle's kit 33 matches attach to an Ancestry-suggested mother, Elizabeth "Betsy" Howard, and one cousin's tree gives the father as James Calvin Brock. That many matches show Solomon belongs to this Brock–Howard kin group. The paper now settles the parents: 1856 Laurel County deeds name James Brock his father and Elizabeth his mother (Confirmed). The middle name Calvin and the maiden name Howard come from trees and one certificate and stay leads.
- James Daniel Bowles × Lydia Williams — one more match agrees. On FamilyTreeDNA the brother has a strong match who also shares part of the X chromosome, and whose own compiled tree runs through this couple. The strength fits the relationship that tree implies. If the X segment comes from this couple it comes from Lydia, because the X reaches the brother through his mother, Robert William Coffman, Lydia Mae Bowles and William Anderson Bowles, who received his X from Lydia and none from his father. Where that segment overlaps Earl's has not been seen. The tree is a lead, so the DNA changes no grade, and it does not bear on the question of Lucy Ann Thomas’s parents.
- Parents of Henry S. Roberts — strong lead. Matches place the suggested pair Henry Roberts × Harriet one generation above Henry S. Roberts; two descend from the pair, the stronger also sharing DNA with known Roberts-side cousins. The paper now agrees: he is in Henry and Harriet Roberts's 1860 and 1870 households at Martins Ferry with the same sisters, and his 1931 death certificate names his mother Harriet, so Henry and Harriet Roberts have cards: Harriet Confirmed as his mother, Henry Probable (strong) as his father. Which of the couple's children the two matches descend from has not been checked, so the DNA stays a lead, and the first cousin's kit adds no match at that distance.
- Louise Rose and Feteira, Faial — weak lead. Four small matches are credited to the suggested couple António Dutra de Mendonça × Luísa Feliciana Bulcão, whom a FamilySearch tree names as Louise Rose's paternal grandparents at Feteira. Small Azorean matches are inflated by island intermarriage.
- Peter Hines Martin's parents — weak lead, a hypothesis. Two distant matches are credited to suggested ancestors (a Sarah Hines as wife of John Martin, and a generation higher John Hines/Haines × Sarah Elizabeth Barham). A mother born Hines would explain Peter's middle name, but each link rests on one small match through a suggested ancestor, and at that distance a single match is no better than chance. The "Hines" idea is a hypothesis to test, not support.
What the first cousin's kit adds (15 October 2026)
Her list was read down to about third-cousin strength: 1,000 matches, and the detail pages of the 551 strongest or ancestor-flagged ones. Ancestry splits her matches by parent. Only 33 fall on the side she shares with Earl; the rest belong to her other parent's family and say nothing about this tree. Of the 33, 31 are already in the brother's list. The ones with a common ancestor name the same couples the brother's matches name — William Harry Proeger × Aileane Silva (3), William Leonard Proeger × Anna Blanche Roberts (5), Antone Rose × Louise (2), the Escobar couple (2) and the Silva couple (2) — so they confirm the father's-side counts above but add no new family. One father's-side match is new to the brother's list, at about second-cousin strength, with no common ancestor shown; it is unplaced for now. No match in her list reaches Julius Karl Proeger's parents, the Roberts couple above Henry S., or Louise Rose's grandparents.
Where the DNA is silent so far
- No independent match descends from Julius Karl Proeger × Minnie Kochendörfer, the German immigrant couple, in either the brother's or the first cousin's kit. The matches whose trees name them all come down through William Leonard Proeger and Anna Blanche Roberts, so they agree with our tree but add nothing independent. That is expected to be thin: the couple have few American descendants and their German cousins rarely test with Ancestry. It is not evidence against them, and the paper record stands. The only sign beyond Julius Karl is a single small match credited through his mother, Elisabethe Sabina Lösch, alone — a weak lead, and no page names Erkenbrechtshausen or any Württemberg place.
- Antone Rose's origin. The matches' trees give him dates only, with no birthplace and no parents.
- Anything above Samuel Coffman. One match reaches Samuel (above), none reaches his father Martin Kaufman, and the question of Samuel's wife is untouched. Y-DNA is the better tool for that surname line.
- Peter Hines Martin's parents in the uncle's kit. None of the uncle's matches names Peter or a parent of his. The Timberman–Martin side is thin in Ancestry's database (about one match in seven of the uncle's falls on it), so DNA may not settle this one; the paper records listed below are the better route.
Ancestry has now recomputed against the full research tree
The common-ancestor labels and shared-surname lists now reach people who are only in the research tree (the Azorean Silva parents, the Kochendörfer and Lösch families, David C. Coffman), which is why the counts above are larger and more specific than the first reading. Forty strong matches (second-to-third-cousin strength) show no common ancestor, and none has a tree. Shared-match grouping places every one of them on the father's or the mother's side, and all but one under a named couple already in this record. No group falls outside the known couples: nothing points to an unknown grandparent or a misattributed parent. The one unplaced match is on the mother's side and is not a warning sign.
What we will pull next
- The marriage record of Henry S. Roberts and Rose A. Williams, about 1876–1878 (Ohio County, West Virginia register, or the Belmont County, Ohio, probate-court marriage volumes), which should name his parents.
- A record that names both Luiza of Feteira and Louise Rose. Her probable baptism (Feteira, 5 June 1856) has been read from the register image, and it names her grandparents as Antonio Dutra de Mendonça and Luiza Feliciana S3590; the identification is still probable, not proven.
- The baptism of the Silva couple's daughter born about 1865, and her marriage entry, in the Cedros, Faial registers.
- Samuel Coffman's will, estate or a deed naming David C. as his son, in the Shenandoah and (from 1831) Page County, Virginia, books.
- A marriage bond for John Martin and Sarah Hines, about 1785–1793, and Sumner County, Tennessee, deeds and wills before 1820 for John Martin.
- Baptism registers of Crailsheim, Triensbach and Kirchberg an der Jagst, 1825–1845 (Archion), for any other child of Elisabetha Sabina Lösch.
The headline has changed: the Azores is now a record, not a DNA result
Updated 16 September 2026. On 13 September this section carried the strongest statement anyone could make about the family's origin: 18.3% Portuguese & Galician out of 21.6% Spanish & Portuguese overall — the order of magnitude one substantially Portuguese grandparent produces S46. It was an inference, and it was labelled one.
The census records say the same. Earl's paternal great-great-grandfather Frank Silva Sr is recorded in the 1900 federal census as born June 1863 in "Azores Port", with the entry "arrived 1888" S47 (he landed at New Orleans on 3 May 1887 from the Nantes, out of Horta S3568), and again in the 1940 census with his birthplace written plainly as "Azores" S50. His wife Annie is "Azores Port" on the same 1900 page. Two enumerations, forty years apart, by different enumerators. The Azorean origin is Confirmed by record. The DNA got there first and got it right; the two census pages are what carry it.
What the DNA still carries alone — and this is the line that must not blur. Within that 18.3% component the results name the Pico and Faial Islands S46. Until 15 September 2026 no record retrieved named any island — every census and index says the archipelago and stops there. On that day a record caught up with half of it: Frank Silva Sr's November 1946 obituary calls him "a native of Fayal, the Azores" S67, corroborated by the two Portuguese fraternal-lodge registers of 1896, which write Fayal against a Francisco da Silva who fits him on age, trade, wife and township S64S65. So the Azores is Confirmed and so is the island — Faial Confirmed, on a document rather than a percentage. Pico is not. It remains a DNA inference alone, stays tagged DNA evidence, and is not promoted on this page, today or by anyone reading it later.
There is a second thing the DNA still cannot do, and it is worth keeping next to the first: it cannot name a parent. Every individual link on the Silva line rests on a census relationship column or a vital record — Son, Granddaughter, Father Of Bride — not on a percentage.
The composition, in full
DNA evidenceAutosomal ancestry estimate · read 13 September 2026
How the rest of the numbers line up against the paper
47.0% Western European ↔ the Proeger German line. Julius Karl Proeger was born at Kirchberg an der Jagst, Oberamt Gerabronn, Württemberg in 1844 S69 and Minnie Margaret Kochendoerfer in Germany in 1847, and both are buried in Pittsburgh S19S44. The largest component in the test is the line this record documents most deeply.
28.9% British & Irish ↔ the Bowles, Wright and Brock lines. Kentucky,
Tennessee, Virginia and Texas — Owsley County, Laurel County, Sumner County,
Callahan County S22S23.
Colonial-stock American families of that geography read as British and Irish, and they are
most of the maternal half of this chart.
The Coffmans are not in that bucket, and it is worth saying why. The Virginia
geography alone would put them under British & Irish. The 1940 Kauffman-Coffman genealogy S66
makes them Swiss-German Kauffmans of the Shenandoah Valley who anglicised to Coffman
— which is also why the Page County clerks indexed them KAUFMAN
S82. The composition has a band that fits them far
better: Swiss and Southwestern German, 20.8% S46,
which had otherwise been read as the Proeger and Kochendoerfer half alone. A surname
that was anglicised on arrival will sort itself into the wrong continent if you file it by
the county it ended up in.
1.2% Nordic — a test the tree could have failed, and did not
There is a Norwegian line in this record: Gertie Selma Selland, born 1903 at Clear Lake, South Dakota, and the Sellands above her S40S41. It belongs to Kristin, not to Earl — it comes down her mother's side, through the Peters and Selland families of Deuel County.
So a test of Earl's DNA should show very little Nordic ancestry. It shows 1.2%. That is the prediction, and it is worth stating precisely because it could have come out the other way. A large Nordic reading here would have meant something in this record was wrong — a line attached to the wrong spouse, or a branch on the wrong side of the family. It did not. The negative result is evidence too, and it is the only part of this section that tested the structure of the tree rather than an origin.
The relative matches are not published, and will not be
Earl's 23andMe test returns a list of roughly 1,500 DNA relatives. The closest predicted relationship on it is aunt-level, at about 10% shared DNA. The AncestryDNA, GEDmatch and FamilyTreeDNA lists for the relatives' tests are larger still. Individual matches stay private. The only things this page publishes about any match list are counts per ancestral couple, as in the section above.
Every one of those matches is a living person who took a DNA test for their own reasons and never agreed to appear in anybody's family record. No name, no initials, no username, no individual percentage, no segment count and no description specific enough to identify one of them is published here. The exports stay in a private research directory and are not copied onto this site. This is the same rule the rest of the page runs on — living people are named only where they are the family's own, and here not even that.
Haplogroups — the surname line and the thinnest paper stretch
Read from Earl's own 23andMe account on 17 September 2026 S100S101:
- Paternal Y haplogroup: I-S17250 (I1, Northern European / Scandinavian-Germanic). Follows the Proeger / Prüger surname line — Julius Karl Proeger, b. Gerabronn 1844, sailed Hamburg 1865. Worth noting rather than assuming: I1 is characteristically Northern European and Scandinavian-Germanic, not the R1b one would casually predict for a Swabian family. It is entirely at home in Germany, but it is a real fact about the male line that the paper record cannot supply.
- Maternal mtDNA haplogroup: J1c1. Follows Nancy Coffman → Louise Timberman → Nancy Martin → Nannie Chenault — once the thinnest stretch of the paper trail above Louise; Nannie's own death certificate now dates her S208.
FamilyTreeDNA: Free autosomal transfer completed for Earl. A brother's data was added on 12 October 2026; his match list has so far been read only for its strongest Bowles match, described above. Y/mtDNA haplogroups = Unknown — a free transfer does not call these; it requires a paid Y-DNA test (~$119–169).
GEDmatch: Kit and GEDCOM uploaded for Earl; the parental-relatedness tool has run (next section). A brother's data was added on 12 October 2026; its one-to-many results were still processing when last checked that day and have not been read since.
GEDmatch "Are Your Parents Related?" — the result is clean
Largest segment = 0 cM. No runs of homozygosity. Earl's parents — William Leonard Proeger and Nancy Martin Coffman — are not related to each other S102.
This does NOT test the Silva/Rose endogamy question. Both the Silva and Rose lines sit on Earl's father's side — Aileane Marie Silva was his father's mother, and Mildred Rose her mother. A Silva×Rose connection therefore lands entirely within one parent's ancestry and produces no ROH in Earl at all. The test that would answer it requires Earl's father's kit — the single highest-value DNA move still pending.
History of this page. 19 Nov 2026 — the “pull next” list still asked for Louise Rose’s Feteira baptism, which was read on 19 Nov (S3590); the item now asks for a record tying Luiza of Feteira to Louise Rose. SWEEP-1119K. 13 Oct 2026 — the warning signs in front of four standing cautions were taken off; the cautions stand as they were. The paragraph on the Coffmans had read “The Coffmans have been moved out of that bucket … This section used to file them under British & Irish on the strength of the Virginia geography alone”; it now states where they sit, and the earlier filing is recorded here.
What the DNA says · Sources
Citations
Sources cited on this page
21 of the record's sources are cited here. The numbering is the record's own; the full list, with where else each is cited, is at Sources.
- S19FindAGrave memorials 85739377 (Julius Karl Proeger, 1844–1924) and 85739357 (Minnie Margaret Kochendoerfer Proeger, memorialised 1848–1912; the year is superseded by [S137]), Smithfield East End Cemetery, Pittsburgh — findagrave.com/memorial/85739377.
- S22FindAGrave memorial 63936320, William Anderson Bowles (1858–1936), Potosi Cemetery — findagrave.com/memorial/63936320.
- S23FindAGrave memorial 63936483, Iona Belle Brock Bowles (1865–1947), Potosi Cemetery — findagrave.com/memorial/63936483.
- S40Obituaries of Dorothy's siblings — LaRoy J. "Pete" Peters (d. 25 January 2021), Miller Funeral Home, Sioux Falls, South Dakota, millerfh.com; and Betty Jane Sanders (d. 10 September 2013), Pitts Chapel, Bolivar, Missouri, via Legacy.com. A third, Shirley Darlene Peltier's (May 2026), names the same parents. Two funeral homes, two states, eight years apart, both spelling the mother's maiden name Selland. Betty's names "Dorothy Walker of Fort Worth, TX" as a sibling, which is what proves it is this family and not a same-name collision.
- S41FindAGrave memorials 70460076 and 70460158 — Benjamin L. Peters (1905–1993), plot Block C Lot 16 Grave E2, and Selma Selland Peters (1903–1991), Grave E1, the adjacent plot — Lakeview Cemetery, Clear Lake, Deuel County, South Dakota. Headstone transcriptions. Benjamin's SSA death date and the stone agree exactly. Family links on FindAGrave are contributor-asserted and are corroboration only; the obituaries at S40 carry the finding on their own.
- S44California, County Birth and Death Records, 1800–1994, via FamilySearch — William Leonard Proeger, death 14 December 1955, Los Angeles; birth 1876; parents: Julius Proeger. A state vital record, not a user tree. It is the document that promotes the join between Earl's great-grandfather and Julius Karl Proeger from Probable to Confirmed. The separate California Death Index 1940–1997 entry for the same man gives the same death date and a birth of 22 March 1876 in Pennsylvania, but abbreviates the parent field to the surname alone.
- S46Autosomal DNA — Ancestry Composition report, 23andMe, Earl's own test, read 13 September 2026 (report version dated 15 September 2025). Supplies the percentages quoted in What the DNA says: European 99.2% · Western European 47.0% · British & Irish 28.9% · Spanish & Portuguese 21.6%, of which Portuguese & Galician 18.3% (Pico and Faial Islands) · Nordic 1.2% · Italian & Maltese 0.5% · Western Asian & North African 0.8%. Not a document, and not treated as one — everything drawn from it carries DNA evidence and nothing on this page is promoted to Confirmed on its strength. The account is deliberately not linked and no login is given. The same account holds a DNA Relatives match list of roughly 1,500 living people; none of it is reproduced, cited or linked here, in aggregate or otherwise, beyond the single sentence in that section, and the raw export is held in the private research directory only.
- S47US Census, 1900 — Washington Township, ED 404, Alameda County, California; household 278, sheet 14B line 75. FamilySearch
ark:/61903/1:1:M9P7-T13. An index entry for the 1900 sheet, not a reading of the page. The FamilySearch index gives Frank Sr as 37, born June 1863, birthplace "Azores Port", arrival 1888, Head, married 13 years, and both of his parents born in "Azores Port"; his wife Annie, 34, "Azores Port"; daughter Mary, 4; son Frank, 3, California. The page itself reads one year lower in all four age cells: 36, 33, 3 and 2 [S141], and where the two differ this record follows the image. The index spells the surname "Frank Silver", which is why a search for Silva does not find the household. - S50US Census, 1940 — Washington Judicial Township, Niles, ED 1-180, Alameda County. FamilySearch
ark:/61903/1:1:K9Q4-7JC. Frank Silva, age 76, birthplace "Azores", Head, Widowed, residence in 1935 "Same House." The second of two federal enumerations forty years apart that name the archipelago — and, like the first, it names no island. This entry is the FamilySearch index, which files the return under Niles; the printed header of the sheet reads Mission San Jose [S149], and the sheet is preferred. The two places lie a few miles apart in Washington Township, and Mission San Jose is the "Mission San" birthplace on Aileane's own NUMIDENT. - S64UPEC Council No. 10 "Amor do Proximo", Mission San Jose — membership register, 1891–1913. União Portuguesa do Estado da California; PDF scan of the LDS microfilm hosted by Azores GenWeb, file
mission-san-jose_2-10.pdf(the file is Council No. 10 only, despite its name). Page 21, member No. 66, February 1896: Francisco da Silva, 33, lavrador, [M.S.J.], Paiz Fayal — a struck Portugal beneath; page 22, heir certificate 2223: Anna da Silva. Re-read at 200 dpi on 15 September 2026. The first record of any kind to name an island for this family. Age within a year of Frank Sr's June 1863, a farmer, wife Anna, in the family's township. Probable, not Confirmed: the row carries no birth date, no parish and no parents, and "Francisco da Silva" is a common name in this colony. It is read with S65, not alone. - S65IDES Council No. 1, Mission San Jose — membership register, book 2, 1889–1946. Irmandade do Divino Espírito Santo; PDF scan of the LDS microfilm hosted by Azores GenWeb, file
ides_council_1_bk2.pdf. Page 21, member No. 178 (admitted 15 November 1896, suspended 3 October 1897): Francisco da Silva, 33, cazado, trabalhador, mission San Jose, Naturalidade Faial. Page 79, member No. 220, 5 April 1914: Frank Silva, 16, [solteiro], [trabalhador], San Jose / Mission, Naturalidade Mission; page 80, heir certificate 16362: Anna L. Silva, Mãi (mother), San Jose / Mission. Re-read at 200 dpi on 15 September 2026. The 1896 row is the same man as S64 in the neighbouring lodge — same name, age, town, marital state and island. The 1914 row is Frank T. Silva Jr: 16 in April 1914 fits 2 December 1897 exactly, he is California-born ("Mission"), and he names Anna L. Silva — the exact form on her death index and headstone — as his mother, in the same book. That pairing is what made Faial a strong inference from these books alone; neither book carries a birth date, so neither settles it. His 1946 obituary [S67] does, and it names these same two lodges — which is also what confirms that these rows are him. - S66Charles Fahs Kauffman, A Genealogy and History of the Kauffman-Coffman Families of North America, 1584 to 1937 (York, PA, 1940), 834 pp. Free scan held at Archive.org, Allen County Public Library copy. Searched twice, to opposite effect. On 15 September 2026 the full text was searched for "Page County," "Luray," "David Coffman," "David Kaufman," "Dee," and "Emily": the Luray branch is present (D-series, ~55 Shenandoah and ~58 Rockingham mentions), but no match to Dee Coffman (b. 1857) or to his parents by those names was found, and the Page County wall was broken through the vital registers instead [S82]. On 16 September, with David Carl Coffman's name and dates in hand from his gravestone [S83], a second search on the new names reached entry FI1a, p. 562, which gives his exact dates (13 Dec 1812 – 25 Jan 1883) and names his father Samuel Coffman (b. 1779) and his mother Susanna Coffman (22 Jul 1779 – 25 Apr 1865), with Martin "Hawkbill" Coffman (d. 1809) a generation above, citing his will at Shenandoah Co. Will Bk. H, p. 338. A compiled secondary source. A 1940 published genealogy is a scholar's reading of records, not a record; each link it supplies is graded on the records read for it, not on the book. The will it cites is read from the image [S1337]. Samuel is Confirmed as David C.'s father by two Library of Virginia registers (his 1871 marriage licence and 1883 death register, both naming "Saml. Coffman"). The 1814 death date is unsourced and probably wrong: the 1820 census shows him still heading a household, and a Samuel Kauffman estate appears in Page County probate — Page County did not exist until 1831. The book's citation for the will of Martin "Hawkbill" Coffman, "Will Bk. H, p. 338, 1809", is right: the will was signed 20 September 1809, proved 8 February 1813, and names "my two sons, Samuel and Jacob Kaufman" [S1337]. The 1805 will with seven sons and no Samuel is that of a different Martin Coffman, of the White House. Martin as Samuel's father is Confirmed on the will, a Page County chancery bill of 1833 [S1338] and an 1835 deed [S1342]. The book also disagrees with the records on Emily: it calls her Emily Thornton, gives her birth as 17 April where the stone reads 7 April, and her death as 1867 where the stone and the Page County register say 1868. The stones are followed.
- S67Frank Silva Sr — obituary, November 1946. Syndicated death notice datelined Mission San Jose, Nov. 28, retrieved 15 September 2026 as two independent OCR captures of the same text on Newspapers.com (Publisher Extra, via Ancestry All Access), image ids
205259611and205515816. "Frank Silva, 83, resident of this community for more than 50 years and former farmer and grocer, died at the San Jose Hospital yesterday… interment will be at St. Joseph's Cemetery… He was a native of Fayal, the Azores, and was a member of IDES Lodge No. 1, St. Anthony's Sodality and the UPEC Lodge. He was the husband of the late Anna L. Silva, the foster father of Frank S. Vargas, father of the late Frank Silva Jr. and Mamie Silva and grandfather of Aileen Roberts of Philadelphia." The record that confirmed the island. Not one indexed field: it independently corroborates every axis the lodge registers rested on — age 83 (b. ~1863), Mission San José, both lodges, wife Anna L., son Frank Jr — and adds the granddaughter by her married name. The second capture's OCR reads "Azures" for Azores: a scanning slip, not a variant place. It also overturns the "d. Santa Barbara County" reading this page had taken from the California Death Index; the index is simply incomplete for Alameda County. - S69Carl Julius Prüger — Lutheran baptism, Kirchberg an der Jagst (Oberamt Gerabronn), Württemberg, 28 April 1844. Württemberg, Germany, Lutheran Baptisms, Marriages, and Burials, 1500–1985 (Ancestry collection 61023), retrieved 16 September 2026. Born 15 April 1844, between 11 and 12 noon, baptised 28 April 1844 at Kirchberg an der Jagst, Oberamt Gerabronn, Württemberg — the register writes the place Gerabronn, Kirchberg u. Oa. (today Baden-Württemberg); father Georg Melchior Julius Prüger, Bürger und Schuhmachermeister dahier; mother Elisabeth Catharina geb. Lösch. Entry no. 22, original scan 5759 × 4607 px. The record that ended the "somewhere in Germany" wall on this line, and the origin of the Prüger spelling that was anglicised to Proeger in America. The identification rests on an exact birth-date match with S68, not on the name alone. The register names the mother, with the surname Lösch. At full resolution the line is legible; the Schrift im Falz verdeckt flag on the film refers to a gutter this entry sits clear of. Its given name for her, Elisabeth Catharina, is a slip: her own baptism, marriage and burial entries say Elisabetha Sabina (S1688, S1689, S133). The parish is Kirchberg an der Jagst and the Oberamt is Gerabronn: the siblings' entries read Kirchberg (OA. Gerabronn), and Julius gave Kirchberg as his home to the Hamburg clerk in 1865.
- S82David Emily "Dee" Coffman — Page County, Virginia birth register, 8 August 1857. Virginia, Bureau of Vital Statistics, Birth Records 1853–1896, FamilySearch ARK
1:1:6K1Q-DYSJ, with the same original entry indexed twice more — Virginia, Births and Christenings 1584–1917, ARK1:1:XT4Y-1S9, and Virginia, Vital Records 1715–1912, ARK1:1:XSVY-N9PV. Retrieved 15 September 2026. The child is entered as David E. Kaufman; the parents as David C. and Emily M. The register indexes this family as KAUFMAN while every census writes COFFMAN — that spelling split is the whole reason the wall stood, because a search on Coffman against Page County returns nothing but Shenandoah drift. The three indexings disagree on the year: 1857 in the Bureau register, 1858 in the christenings collection. The page follows 1857, which the stated age of 80 on his 1938 death record and the family typescript both support. The register gives the parents by given name and middle initial only; "Thornhill" is not in this record and comes from the censuses and her gravestone. - S10023andMe Paternal Haplogroup report — Y-DNA haplogroup I-S17250 (I1, Northern European / Scandinavian-Germanic). Read 17 September 2026 from Earl's own 23andMe account. Follows the PROEGER / Prüger surname line. I1 is not the R1b one would casually predict for a Swabian family.
- S10123andMe Maternal Haplogroup report — mtDNA haplogroup J1c1. Read 17 September 2026. Follows Nancy Coffman → Louise Timberman → Nancy Martin → Nannie Chenault — the thinnest stretch of the paper trail.
- S102GEDmatch "Are Your Parents Related?" — Earl’s own kit. Largest segment 0 cM, no runs of homozygosity. Read 17 September 2026. Earl's parents are not related to each other. This does not test the Silva/Rose endogamy question — both lines are on Earl's father's side. The test that would answer it requires Earl's father's kit.
- S208Tennessee death certificate, Sumner County, Reg. No. 41 — Mrs Nannie C. Martin, 14 April 1915. Ancestry record 320718. Read from the image at full resolution, 22 September 2026. Mrs Nannie C. Martin, widow, born 26 January 1844, died 14 April 1915, 10th Civil District, three miles east of Gallatin; father D. Chenault (Ky.); mother "Lizzie Eastberry" (Ky.); buried Gallatin Cemetery 16 April; informant J. [R.?] Martin. A primary record of Nannie's birth and death. The mother's surname is hard to read. Nannie's card takes its dates from this certificate, 26 January 1844 – 14 April 1915.
- S3568New Orleans passenger list, SS Nantes from Fayal (Horta), arrived 3 May 1887. NARA M259, Passenger Lists of Vessels Arriving at New Orleans, 1820–1902, roll 70, image LAM259_70-0205. Ancestry, “New Orleans, Louisiana, U.S., Passenger Lists, 1813–1963” (db 7484), record 685948. Image examined, read 19 November 2026. Confirmed Row 55: Silva, Francisco, 24, destination San Francisco. Below the list, the French vice-consul at Horta certifies it, 16 April. The list gives no parish or marital status. It is tied to Frank Silva Sr through his Horta passport of 1 April 1887 [S3567]: the same name and age, a steamer with a name in N, and the dates fit. The first sheet, with the ship’s header, was not captured.
- S3590Paróquia do Espírito Santo, Feteira (Horta, Faial), Livro de baptismos 1845–1860 — Luiza, b. 5 June, bapt. 15 June 1856. BPARJJG via CulturAçores, FAL-HT-FETEIRA-B-1845-1860, images 0270–0271. FamilySearch index: Portugal, Azores, Church Records, persona 6JZK-5VN1 (FamilySearch image restricted). Image read 19 November 2026. Daughter of Francisco Dutra (d’Utra) de Mendonça and Francisca Eugénia; grandparents Antonio Dutra de Mendonça × Luiza Feliciana and Manoel Francisco da Rosa × Maria Felicia. The entry is Confirmed as read; that this Luiza is Louise Rose is probable.
Know something this page doesn't? Send it to Earl — corrections, names, dates, documents. Nothing appears here until he has reviewed it.